Leeds City Council (25 019 406)

Category : Planning > Enforcement

Decision : Upheld

Decision date : 04 Oct 2026

The Ombudsman's final decision:

Summary: The evidence currently suggests fault on Mr Y’s complaint about the way the Council dealt with his reports of a neighbouring development. It failed to properly explain its decision not to take enforcement action to him. The Council agreed to apologise to him for failing to properly explain the decision. It also agreed to remind planning enforcement officers of the need to properly explain decisions not to take enforcement action to those making reports.

The complaint

  1. Mr Y complains that following his reports to the Council about a neighbouring development that had no planning consent, it failed to properly:
      1. investigate and assess his reports;
      2. communicate with him about it; and
      3. consider whether a planning application was needed.
  2. As a result, his amenities are affected, water run-off is entering his property, he has lost privacy, and lost the opportunity to object to the development and have these considered.

Back to top

The Ombudsman’s role and powers

  1. If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
  2. We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)

Back to top

How I considered this complaint

  1. I considered evidence provided by Mr Y, the response received from the Council to my enquiries, as well as relevant law, policy, and guidance. I sent a copy of my draft decision to Mr Y and the Council. I considered their responses.

Back to top

What I found

Planning law and guidance

Enforcement

  1. Councils can take enforcement action if they find a breach of planning rules. However, councils should not take enforcement action just because there has been a breach of planning control.
  2. Planning enforcement is discretionary and formal action should happen only when it would be a proportionate response to the breach. When deciding whether to enforce, councils should consider the likely impact of harm to the public and whether they might grant approval if they were to receive an application for the development or use.
  3. As planning enforcement action is discretionary, councils may decide to take informal action or not to act at all. Informal action might include negotiating improvements, seeking an assurance or undertaking, or requesting submission of a planning application so they can formally consider the issues.
  4. Government guidance says: “Effective enforcement is important as a means of maintaining public confidence in the planning system. Enforcement action is discretionary, and local planning authorities should act proportionately in responding to suspected breaches of planning control.” (National Planning Policy Framework December 2024, paragraph 60)
  5. Recently, the National Planning Policy Framework was updated. It now says:

“Where there has been unauthorised development and local planning authorities are considering whether enforcement action is expedient, they should take account of their local enforcement plan, the impact of the breach of planning control, and the extent to which the breach would otherwise be acceptable.

In cases of unauthorised development where consideration is being given to an

application for retrospective planning permission (or through an enforcement appeal, whether to grant planning permission in respect of a breach of planning control), if it is concluded based on evidence that the unauthorised development was intentional, that fact should be given substantial weight in considering whether to grant planning permission.” (National Planning Policy Framework August 2026, DM8)

Leeds Enforcement Plan for Planning

  1. The Council will not always act when there is a breach of planning control. It is required to consider the expediency of doing so and the harm caused by the breach. Enforcement is not to be taken solely to regularise a matter that is acceptable and would gain planning consent.
  2. Certain types of building works or changes of use are ‘permitted development’ which means a planning application is not needed.
  3. It will need to consider whether the breach affects the quality of life or amenity of an area. While it does not always have to take action, the particular circumstances of the case need considering.

Permitted development

  1. The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 allows certain types of development without the need for planning consent provided they are within certain limitations. Planning consent is automatically granted for certain types of development.
  2. Class E of Schedule 2 of the Order allows certain types of buildings incidental to the enjoyment of a dwellinghouse. One of the restrictions is the height of the building, enclosure, or container, cannot exceed 2.5 metres within two metres of the boundary. Another is it cannot include the construction, or provision, of a veranda, balcony, or raised platform.
  3. Class F of Schedule 2 of the Order allows hard surfaces incidental to the enjoyment of a dwellinghouse.
  4. References to ‘height’ means the height measured from ground level. This is the surface of the ground immediately adjacent to the building in question and would not include any addition laid on top of the ground such as decking. Where ground level is not uniform (for example, sloping) then the ground level is the highest part of the of the surface of the ground next to the building. (page 6, Permitted Development Rights for Householders: Technical Guidance September 2019)

What happened

  1. Mr Y’s neighbour built an outbuilding with attached pergola (the outbuilding) along the boundary to his property. It was built where there used to be a garage.
  2. Mr Y complained the outbuilding is too high at 2.77 metres high compared to the original garden boundary level. The neighbour also built a large, raised 0.3 metre patio area with no provision for drainage which means surface run off falls on to his land.
  3. Mr Y alerted the Council to the works as he believed there was no planning consent. He also told the Council he considered the works were outside of permitted development rights because of the height and area covered.
  4. When the Council received Mr Y’s report, it contacted the neighbour for dimensions of the decking area and outbuilding. When it received drawings, measurements, and photographs from the neighbour, it considered whether planning consent was needed. When doing this, it considered whether the works came within general permitted development rights.
  5. The Council noted the works done by the neighbour included:
  • erecting decking;
  • creating a patio area;
  • an outbuilding; and
  • changes to garden levels.
  1. The Council sent Mr Y its decision (the decision). This said it was not expedient to take enforcement action and explained enforcement was discretionary. The pergola/outbuilding posts measured 2.5 metres in height, which was within permitted development guidelines. The decking area was considered acceptable as were further alterations to the garden development. While unauthorised, it would not be expedient to take the matter further.
  2. When Mr Y complained about this decision, including the lack of any site visit to view the works, the Council explained there was no requirement for officers to view the site from Mr Y’s land. The officer was satisfied to accept the dimensions given by the neighbour.
  3. When he complained further, the Council said the officer decided:
  • the outbuilding was permitted development as it was 2.5 metres in height and 2 metres from the boundary;
  • the shed element of it was 2 metres in height and replaced a garage;
  • the height measurement was taken from the highest ground level immediately adjacent to the building within the development site, not the neighbouring site; and
  • while the patio decking was not permitted development, it was not expedient to take enforcement action. The officer considered the Leeds Enforcement Plan and decided it did not result in significant harm or unacceptably affected the quality of life or amenity of the area. Drainage and run-off onto neighbouring properties is a private matter between neighbours.
  1. In response to our enquiries, the Council said the raised patio/land level areas were considered acceptable as it sloped downwards from the property to the rear of the garden. The enforcement officer did not consider he needed to check the land level information received and trusted these were correct. No site visit was done as the officer saw photographs from Mr Y and the neighbour. The decking was existing and upgraded. Drainage was not considered as garden landscaping was not a consideration. The outbuilding replaced a garage of similar height although Mr Y disputes this saying it is now 30 cms higher.

My findings

  1. I found the following on this complaint:
      1. I find no fault with the investigation process the Council followed when it received Mr Y’s reports. It contacted the neighbour and received information and drawings, copies of which I have seen.
      2. There was no obligation for the Council to visit the site when it received his report. Under its enforcement policy, it would carry out initial checks to see if planning consent exists or the works came within permitted development rights.
      3. When it decided not to take enforcement action, the Council had information from Mr Y and the neighbour. It decided while the outbuilding fell within permitted development, the patio area did not. It decided not to take any action about the patio having considered all the circumstances of the case. This was because there was no significant harm and it did not unacceptably affect the quality of life or amenity of the area.
      4. I have seen the decision sent to Mr Y. While it explained enforcement is discretionary and explained the measurement of the outbuilding fell within permitted development guidelines, it failed to say which category it came within and why. While it explained the decking was acceptable, as further alterations to the garden development, it did not explain why.
      5. I consider the decision sent to Mr Y failed to properly: give enough information to allow him to fully understand it; explain the reasoning for the decision not to take enforcement action for the whole of the site. We expect councils to provide reasons for planning decisions, and I am not satisfied this was properly done with this decision. This failure is fault.
      6. The Council later told Mr Y the pergola was two metres from the boundary. This was not correct. The pergola part of the outbuilding starts along the boundary with Mr Y and extends into the neighbouring garden. The structure itself acts as a fence line for about six metres.
      7. The Stage 2 letter wrongly said the officer concluded the outbuilding was permitted development because it was 2.5 metres in height and 2 metres from the boundary. This gave the impression the Council believed the outbuilding was set back from the boundary. Permitted development rights refer to the need for a structure to be within two metres of the boundary. Had it been two metres from the boundary, it would have been assessed differently.
      8. The Stage 2 letter also explained the patio area did not result in significant harm or unacceptably affect the quality of life or amenity of the area
      9. The need to give Mr Y additional information about the decision during the complaint procedure could have been avoided had the decision given proper reasons at the time.
      10. I am satisfied the Council did not consider it necessary to ask the neighbour to make a formal retrospective planning application.
      11. I am satisfied the fault found caused Mr Y some injustice. He suffered some avoidable frustration with the information the Council sent to him.
      12. I am not satisfied Mr Y suffered any further injustice. This is because the evidence shows the outbuilding replaced the garage. The evidence shows the garage was in the same location with a similar height. It was built on the existing garage concrete base which was not removed along with the garage.

Back to top

Action

  1. I considered our guidance on remedies.
  2. The Council agreed to take the following action within four weeks of the final decision on this complaint:
      1. Send Mr Y a written apology for failing to properly explain its decision not to take enforcement action against his neighbour.
      2. Remind planning enforcement officers of the need to properly explain decisions to not take enforcement action to those making reports.
  3. The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above actions.

Back to top

Decision

  1. I found fault on Mr Y’s complaint against the Council. The agreed action remedies the injustice caused.

Back to top

Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman

Print this page

LGO logogram

Review your privacy settings

Required cookies

These cookies enable the website to function properly. You can only disable these by changing your browser preferences, but this will affect how the website performs.

View required cookies

Analytical cookies

Google Analytics cookies help us improve the performance of the website by understanding how visitors use the site.
We recommend you set these 'ON'.

View analytical cookies

In using Google Analytics, we do not collect or store personal information that could identify you (for example your name or address). We do not allow Google to use or share our analytics data. Google has developed a tool to help you opt out of Google Analytics cookies.

Privacy settings