Somerset Council (25 014 610)

Category : Planning > Enforcement

Decision : Not upheld

Decision date : 04 Oct 2026

The Ombudsman's final decision:

Summary: The Council was not at fault. It did not delay responding to a breach of planning control at a site adjoining Mr X’s land or communicate poorly with him.

The complaint

  1. Mr X complained the Council decided to negotiate rather than take enforcement action against illegal dumping and burning of waste near his home and the unlawful occupation of the site, despite a high court injunction being in place. Mr X also said the Council delayed taking out a new injunction. Mr X said the Council did not have an up-to-date gypsy and traveller study and the Council communicated poorly. Mr X said it caused him and his family distress and affected their physical and mental health.

Back to top

The Ombudsman’s role and powers

  1. We investigate complaints of injustice caused by ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. I have used the word fault to refer to these. We consider whether there was fault in the way an organisation made its decision. If there was no fault in how the organisation made its decision, we cannot question the outcome. (Local Government Act 1974, section 34(3), as amended)
  2. If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)

Back to top

What I have not investigated

  1. I have not considered investigations carried out by the police in relation to harassment claims or issues Mr X raised with the police. The law says we cannot investigate a complaint if it is about action taken by or on behalf of any local policing body in connection with the investigation or prevention of crime. (Local Government Act 1974, Schedule 5, Section 26, paragraph 2 as amended)

Back to top

How I considered this complaint

  1. I considered evidence provided by the Council and Mr X and spoke to him on the telephone. I also considered relevant law, policy and guidance.
  2. Mr X and the Council had an opportunity to comment on my draft decision. I considered comments received before making a final decision.

Back to top

What I found

Relevant law and guidance

Planning

  1. Councils should approve planning applications that accord with policies in the local development plan unless other material planning considerations say they should not.
  2. Planning considerations include issues like:
    • access to the highway;
    • protection of ecological and heritage assets; and
    • the impact on neighbouring amenity.
  3. Planning considerations do not include things like:
    • views from a property;
    • the impact of development on property value; and
    • private rights and interests in land.

Planning Enforcement

  1. Councils can take enforcement action if they find planning controls have been breached. Planning enforcement is discretionary and formal action should happen only when it would be a proportionate response to the breach. When deciding whether to enforce, councils should consider the likely impact of harm to the public. Government guidance encourages councils to resolve issues through negotiation and dialogue. Informal action might include negotiating improvements, seeking an assurance or undertaking, or requesting submission of a planning application so they can formally consider these issues. Formal planning enforcement action is also available to a council. Councils are free to make their own judgement on how or whether to act.

Council’s enforcement policy

  1. The Council’s planning enforcement policy was published in 2023. In relation to how it will communicate with people raising enforcement concerns it says:
    • it would acknowledge complaints within five working days;
    • it would not give a running commentary on what was happening;
    • it would allow people being complained about time to respond; and
    • it would give updates on significant progress and more serious breaches could take a significant amount of time to progress.
  2. The enforcement policy said it would prioritise each potential breach of planning control into three categories, red, amber and green. The Council confirmed this case was a red priority category for an unauthorised development, advert or breach of condition which was causing irreparable public harm or danger. The policy states, if a breach of planning control had taken place, the Council may decide to conduct a site visit to investigate further.
  3. The enforcement policy also said it will negotiate and use of enforcement powers is discretionary. Any action taken would be proportionate and have regard to the public interest test and expediency test. The policy states it could take enforcement action including:
    • an enforcement notice: which specifies the breach, the steps that must be taken to remedy the breach and a specified time period for compliance; and
    • a stop notice: which must be accompanied by an enforcement notice and served at the same time. A stop notice would ensure any activity that may permanently harm the amenity, public safety or natural environment stops.
  4. The policy states there may be exceptional cases where there is a need to restrain an actual or potential breach of planning control through an injunction. It states due to the high costs involved, an injunction is only used as a last resort and where the Council determines other action is unlikely to succeed.

What happened

Background

  1. Over 20 years ago hardcore was laid on a field adjoining Mr X’s land, the site was cleared of vegetation, an access track constructed and the field was unlawfully occupied. The Council issued an enforcement notice and stop notice which required the occupants to stop any development, remove any development and reinstate the land to the condition it was in before occupation occurred.
  2. Since then, there have been several applications for lawful occupation on the land which were all refused by the Council. There were also several associated public enquiries into the land, each appeal was dismissed. Over 15 years ago the high court served an injunction on the site preventing any future residence on the land. The injunction named specific people and ‘persons unknown’.

October 2024 onwards

  1. On a weekend in late October 2024 Mr X raised concerns with the Council about an incursion of the injunction, with new occupiers living on the land adjoining his land. The same day a Council Planning Officer, Officer 1 visited the site with the police to warn the occupiers of the injunction, potential contempt of court and advised them to cease work. The Council said it was aware at this point the incursion onto the site was a breach of the injunction.
  2. The Council sought legal advice on the enforceability of the injunction because of the amount of time lapsed since the injunction, the change in personal circumstances, change in policies, change in the five-year land supply position for the Council, and case law in respect of injunctions against ‘persons unknown’.
  3. Two Planning Enforcement Officers, Officer 2 and Officer 3 visited the site with copies of the injunction.
  4. In late October and November 2024 Mr X said hundreds of lorries used a narrow lane in front of his house which dumped thousands of tonnes of waste on the site adjoining his land. Mr X said some of the waste was burnt which he said created odour and smoke across his land and some waste was used as hardcore before caravans were put on the site. He said a Council Environmental Health Officer (EHO) visited the site but they were not sure what was being burnt.
  5. Between late 2024 and early 2025 Council Officers 1,2 and 3 visited the site over ten times between them to meet with the occupiers of the site, the Parish Council and police. In January 2025, Officer 2 also visited Mr X at his property.
  6. Mr X was concerned the Council was encouraging a planning application for the unlawful use of the site when there was the injunction in place and about delayed legal advice. He said it caused a severe impact on him and other local residents because the whole field became developed. In late January 2025 the Council received a planning application on the site to change the use of land from agricultural to caravan pitches, parking and landscaping.
  7. In mid-February 2025 a public meeting was held. Members of the Parish Council attended alongside approximately 170 members of the public, three senior Council officers and Council Officers 1,2 and 3 also attended the meeting. The Parish Council minutes of the meeting noted Council officers answered questions raised and explained the Council was ‘looking to enforce the injunction’. The Council committed to monthly engagement with the Parish Council and people linked to the enforcement case and updates would be provided on the Parish Council’s website and on social media. The Council said there was no delay between the incursion and the Council taking action and it was a slow process. It said it was seeking legal advice on whether the recent planning application had to be considered and determined and the application would not stop the injunction being enforced.
  8. Council Officer’s 2 and 3 carried out regular site visits between March and July 2025 and an EHO visited the site. The planning application submitted in late January 2025 was registered by the Council and the Council served legal documents for an interim injunction on the site following legal advice obtained by the Council.
  9. In early July 2025 Mr X complained to the Council about delays in enforcing the existing injunction and encouraging a new planning application. Mr X said the Council had showed no understanding, empathy or respect for those impacted by the site, treating residents unfairly, allowing the destruction of habitats on the site and failed to publish an up-to-date needs assessment of gypsy and traveller sites.
  10. In mid-July 2025 the Council sent Mr X its stage one complaint response. It said it was providing monthly updates to the Parish Council and a court date for the interim injunction had been set for late July 2025 which would prohibit any further activity on the site and it could not comment further at that stage on the legal proceedings due to confidentiality. It said it was undertaking a gypsy and traveller accommodation assessment as part of the Local Plan. It said it aimed to investigate concerns raised and worked proactively with parties to negotiate and resolve issues where possible and undertook site visits. It apologised if Mr X felt the Council’s approach lacked empathy and respect but said that was not its intention.
  11. In late July 2025 Mr X remained unhappy and escalated his complaint to stage two of the Council’s complaint process.
  12. In late July 2025 an interim injunction was served which prevented further occupation of the land for residential purposes, by persons other than the named defendants and further works associated with the unauthorised use. The Council also sought a hearing from the high court to permanently evict those currently living there. Mr X said some people left the site after the interim injunction was served but people still lived on the site.
  13. In early September 2025 the Council sent Mr X its final complaint response and said the Council did not delay taking legal advice. It said its enforcement team actively investigated, sought and acted on legal advice and an application to the high court for an interim injunction had been made, granted and served. It said enforcement processes are complex and must be legally robust, which takes time. It apologised for any unintended lack of empathy and the appropriate procedures were followed. It said the loss of landscaping was considered in line with the Wildlife and Countryside Act as part of a planning application and any enforcing breaches of this act would be considered by Natural England and gave Mr X information about Natural England. It did not uphold Mr X’s complaint and gave our contact details. Mr X remained unhappy and complained to us.

Enquiries

  1. In response to my enquiries Mr X said the Council refused the planning application submitted in late January 2025 and the planning inspectorate also dismissed a legal challenge on the application. He said the high court hearing was held in summer 2026 but a decision was still to be made.
  2. In response to my enquiries, the Council said:
    • it initially responded to all complaints about the site made by the public individually but that was unsustainable and not transparent. It then adopted a new communication strategy providing monthly updates to the Parish Council and set up a social media group so immediate neighbours could report ‘live’ issues which was reviewed regularly and Mr X was made aware of the appeal decision and court dates.
    • there were landscaping and boundary issues. It said it made site visits after concerns were raised and advice was given to the occupants with replanting negotiated. It said the landscaping issues formed a reason for refusal of the planning application which was upheld by the Planning Inspector. It said this confirmed the Council was correct to seek to remedy the breach of planning through a permanent injunction; and
    • the Council and public enquiry considered the previous and more recent gypsy and traveller assessments when the planning application was refused.
  3. In response to my draft decision the Council said the high court granted a final injunction to stop residential occupation and clear the site.

My findings

  1. We are not a planning appeal body. Our role is to review the process by which planning decisions are made. We look for evidence of fault causing a significant injustice to the individual complainant. I have considered the processes by which the decisions were made and my findings are as follows.
  2. Planning enforcement is discretionary and government guidance encourages negotiation and advises that formal action should generally be used as a last resort. The evidence shows as soon as the Council was made aware of the breach of planning control in late October 2024 it carried out a site visit the same day and warned the occupiers of the high court injunction, potential contempt of court and advised them to cease work. This was an option available to the Council to address breaches of planning control. The Council continued to carry out regular site visits when issues and concerns were raised. It also sought legal advice in relation to the original high court injunction and in accordance with legal advice it considered an application at the site which was refused. In summer 2025 the Council obtained an interim injunction. The formal enforcement route was an option it was entitled to use.
  3. Although it was a long process from first acknowledging the breach of planning control, and I understand the occupiers of the land caused Mr X and his family distress, the Council took steps to try and resolve the breach. The Council has been able to account for its actions and decisions, it considered the breach of control and its powers, it considered the impact on landscaping and gypsy and traveller assessments through the planning application and public enquiry and determined that the court process and seeking a permanent injunction was the right approach in this case. A final injunction has now been granted by the high court. I have not found fault by the Council. This is because it followed the decision-making process we would expect without any unnecessary delays. It therefore reached decisions it was entitled to.
  4. Mr X was also unhappy about the Council’s communication. The Council carried out site visits at Mr X’s home, attended a public meeting, initially started to respond to all concerns raised and then over time changed its communication strategy by giving monthly updates. It also provided a social media communication method so Mr X and other local residents could quickly raise concerns. The Council acted in line with its policy by providing Mr X with significant updates. The Council was not at fault.

Back to top

Decision

  1. I have completed this investigation finding no fault.

Back to top

Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman

Print this page

LGO logogram

Review your privacy settings

Required cookies

These cookies enable the website to function properly. You can only disable these by changing your browser preferences, but this will affect how the website performs.

View required cookies

Analytical cookies

Google Analytics cookies help us improve the performance of the website by understanding how visitors use the site.
We recommend you set these 'ON'.

View analytical cookies

In using Google Analytics, we do not collect or store personal information that could identify you (for example your name or address). We do not allow Google to use or share our analytics data. Google has developed a tool to help you opt out of Google Analytics cookies.

Privacy settings