Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council (25 020 817)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: Mr D says the Council mishandled his homelessness case, and he was subject to a sexual assault in his interim accommodation. I have found fault by the Council because it delayed progressing the homelessness application and delayed rehousing Mr D after the alleged assault. The Council has agreed to pay Mr D redress and has made a service improvement.
The complaint
- The complainant (whom I refer to as Mr D) says the Council failed to carry out sufficient suitability checks before placing him in interim accommodation where he was sexually assaulted. Mr D also says the Council failed to assist him with a deposit for a private sector rental property and did not activate his housing register account.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
- If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
What I have and have not investigated
- I have considered events from October 2024 through to November 2025 when the Council issued its final stage complaint response.
How I considered this complaint
- I considered evidence provided by Mr D, his representative and the Council as well as relevant law, policy and guidance.
- I shared my draft decision with both parties and considered their comments.
What I found
What happened
2024
- On 31 October 2024, the Probation Service made a referral to the Council that Mr D was homeless. By the 7 November the Probation Service had notified the Council Mr D was a rough sleeper. The Council says it opened a triage case to make an initial assessment. I have no record of any significant action on the case up to 13 November when a Probation Service Officer called the Council. The Probation Service also emailed the Council on 14 November; they had been told the homelessness application was ‘pending’ and an Officer would call Mr D on 13 November however Mr D had not been contacted. Mr D’s mental health was deteriorating due to being street homeless. The same day the Council noted it had called Mr D, but the call cut out. A homelessness assessment was completed by a Housing Officer who recorded they had spoken to Mr D, and he had priority need and would be provided with interim accommodation. They emailed Mr D a letter explaining a relief duty had been accepted and Mr D needed to bring documentation to the Council.
- On 15 November Mr D was placed into interim accommodation. The Council noted “suitability done”. The Council has provided a temporary accommodation placement referral form (referral form) for the accommodation which notes Mr D’s medical conditions. On 4 December the Council sent Mr D a personalised housing plan (PHP) and a link to set up his housing register account. The PHP stated Mr D needed a one-bedroom property. Due to his medical conditions, he could not use a bath and could only manage one set of stairs. It provided links to find a suitable private sector rental home. It stated the Council would consider assisting with rent and a deposit for a private sector rental property that used the rent deposit scheme.
2025
- On 9 January 2025 the Council contacted Mr D about moving to new interim accommodation. An Officer completed a referral form and noted Mr D’s medical conditions. Mr D moved the following day into alternative interim accommodation. Also on 10 January, the Council asked Mr D to provide documentation to progress his housing register application. On 20 January the Council accepted a main housing duty towards Mr D and wrote to him with the decision. At the end of January, the Council told Mr D he could attend its offices to get assistance completing the housing register documentation. It reiterated what documents it needed to progress the application.
- On 7 February a psychiatrist raised a safeguarding concern with the Council because Mr D had disclosed a man had come into his room and sexually assaulted him. Adult Social Care (ASC) allocated the case to a Social Worker who tried calling Mr D from 7 to 11 February and sought to meet Mr D on 11 and 12 February. He had an incorrect address for Mr D which was rectified on 13 February, on that day the Social Worker met with Mr D. Mr D stated he did not want to pursue the matter and did not consent to the Police being contacted. He also did not want to identify the alleged perpetrator. On 14 February the Social Worker emailed Housing Services and asked what housing plans the Council had for Mr D. Mr D had stated he was sexually assaulted at the property and his mental health was poor.
- On 20 February an NHS Officer emailed various parties including the Council. They had spoken to Mr D that day and he had disclosed the sexual assault by a resident at the temporary accommodation. Mr D did not want to go to the Police for fear of repercussions. The Officer asked if the Council could move Mr D. An Officer in the Accommodation Team then spoke to Mr D and completed a suitability assessment form. The Council gave Mr D details of a new temporary accommodation he could move to. Mr D moved the next day. On 26 February a Probation Service Officer asked the Council if Mr D was okay in his new accommodation. The Social Worker replied the next day that he had been in touch with Mr D who stated he was more settled in the accommodation than he had been at his previous address.
- On 18 March the Council sent Mr D an updated PHP. In April and May the Council was in touch with Mr D and requested documents for his housing benefit and housing register applications. On 16 May Mr D provided documents to the Council. On 19 May the Council identified that Mr D’s surname differed in some of the documentation he had provided. It contacted him that day and asked for a copy of his deed poll certificate as he had changed his name previously. Mr D subsequently said he did not have a copy of the deed poll certificate and the Council explained how to obtain a copy of the document; it also offered to assist him with ordering a copy. The Council says it has never received a copy of the deed poll information.
- On 20 May Mr D told the Council he had not received a PHP, and he asked about financial assistance to secure private sector housing. On 6 June the Council received a complaint from Mr D and his representative about the handling of his case. Also on 6 June, the Council noted an Officer had spoken to the representative and explained Mr D was on the housing register, but the Council needed Mr D’s deed poll evidence to activate the account. It understood Mr D was unhappy he had to share facilities at the temporary accommodation. The Council had not received any reports from him about the current property until the complaint was received. The Council said it did not have self-contained accommodation for single applicants. It would contact Mr D to discuss his concerns.
- On 10 June the Council spoke to Mr D who said he was struggling in the temporary accommodation because it was all male and this was an issue after the sexual assault. The Council advised Mr D about the option to help with a rent deposit. On 16 June the accommodation provider advised the Council that Mr D had left. The room had been cancelled. The Council called Mr D, but he did not reply. On 17 June the Council replied to the complaint. It said it was first notified about the sexual assault on 20 February and immediately took action to relocate Mr D. The new accommodation had CCTV and staff on site permanently to provide security and support. Mr D had not reported any issues with the recent accommodation until he complained in June. The Council said Mr D had ‘priority 1’ housing need but would still have to wait up to 18 months to be rehoused via social housing. It also asked for the deed poll document to activate the housing register account. It confirmed it had spoken to Mr D and told him about assistance for rent deposits. Also on 17 June, the Council called Mr D, but he did not pick up. It wrote to him explaining it had ended its main duty because he had stopped occupying the temporary accommodation.
- On 9 July the representative requested the Council escalate the complaint. They wanted the Council to pay the deposit and the first month rent on a private sector property. They said Mr D had left the temporary accommodation because he felt vulnerable and had taken an overdose. The Council noted on the same day that it had checked with the Mental Health Team and Mr D had been to hospital for an overdose of medication. He had stated it was not intentional or a suicidal incident. Also on 9 July, the Council asked Mr D/ his representative for information about the private sector rental property. They would check if the accommodation was affordable and then make a payment to the landlord. The Council says it did not receive the information it required.
- On 20 November the Council issued its final stage complaint response. It said it had moved Mr D after it was aware of the sexual assault and advised him to report it to the Police. It was aware at the time that Mr D was in contact with a Social Worker and the Probation Service and they were assisting Mr D with accessing mental health support. The Council felt it had taken the correct steps for safeguarding. It also said it had not heard from Mr D since he left the temporary accommodation in respect of welfare or support issues. Regarding the rent deposit, the Council had confirmed in June to Mr D that it could assist him. It still needed information to assess if the property was suitable and affordable, if it was the Council would make an urgent payment.
What should have happened
Assessments and Personal Housing Plans
- Councils must complete an assessment if they are satisfied an applicant is homeless or threatened with homelessness. The Code of Guidance says, rather than advise the applicant to return when homelessness is more imminent, the housing authority may wish to accept a prevention duty and begin to take reasonable steps to prevent homelessness. Councils must notify the applicant of the assessment. Councils should work with applicants to identify practical and reasonable steps for the council and the applicant to take to help the applicant keep or secure suitable accommodation. These steps should be tailored to the household, and follow from the findings of the assessment, and must be provided to the applicant in writing as their personalised housing plan. (Housing Act 1996, section 189A and Homelessness Code of Guidance paragraphs 11.6 and 11.18)
The relief duty
- Councils must take reasonable steps to help to secure suitable accommodation for any eligible homeless person. When a council decides this duty has come to an end, it must notify the applicant in writing (Housing Act 1996, section 189B)
The main housing duty
- If a council is satisfied an applicant is homeless, eligible for assistance, and has a priority need the council has a duty to secure that accommodation is available for their occupation (unless it refers the application to another housing authority under section 198). But councils will not owe the main housing duty to applicants who have turned down a suitable final accommodation offer or a Housing Act Part 6 offer made during the relief stage, or if a council has given them notice under section 193B(2) due to their deliberate and unreasonable refusal to co-operate. (Housing Act 1996, section 193 and Homelessness Code of Guidance 15.39)
- A council must secure accommodation for applicants and their household if it has reason to believe they may be homeless, eligible for assistance and have a priority need. This is called interim accommodation. (Housing Act 1996, section 188)
- If a council is satisfied an applicant is unintentionally homeless, eligible for assistance, and has a priority need, the council has a duty to secure that accommodation is available for their occupation. This is called the main housing duty. The accommodation a council provides until it can end this duty is called temporary accommodation. (Housing Act 1996, section 193)
- The law says councils must ensure all accommodation provided to homeless applicants is suitable for the needs of the applicant and members of their household. This duty applies to interim and temporary accommodation. (Housing Act 1996, section 206 and Homelessness Code of Guidance 17.2)
Rough sleeper
- When the Council receives a homelessness application it is considered by a Triage Officer. If there is reference to the applicant being a rough sleeper the Triage Officer should flag the case as “homeless tonight” so the Council can assess the case on the same day as a priority. If the Council then accepts a duty to assist the applicant, it will place them in interim accommodation.
Checking the suitability of a placement
- The Council should carry out a suitability assessment before offering a homelessness applicant interim accommodation. An Officer will consider the needs of the applicant including any medical issues that impact on housing. Ideally the applicant should be consulted as part of the process. The outcome is recorded on a referral form. The Council will then share the referral form with the accommodation provider to ensure the accommodation offered is suitable.
Safeguarding
- The Council does not have an automated system that covers all its services to flag up when a safeguarding concern is raised. Where a service area receives a safeguarding report, it will consider if other Council service areas need to be notified and involved.
- Where ASC receive a report about a safeguarding incident relating to a person in Council funded housing it should promptly record and screen the report. Initial information should be gathered and the relevant Housing Services notified “at the earliest opportunity” about accommodation related risks so they can be assessed.
- The Council is not responsible for assessing if a sex offender poses a risk to other people including people who may share accommodation facilities, that is the responsibility of the Police Sex Offender Management Unit and the Probation Service. The Council is unable to disclose to other occupants of interim/ temporary accommodation if a sex offender has been placed in the property.
Rent deposit
- The Council can assist eligible applicants who require a rent deposit to secure a private sector home. The Council will ask the applicant for information including details about the landlord, the applicant’s finances and the amount of the rent. The Council requires that information to assess if the tenancy is affordable and sustainable. It will also need to make checks with the landlord. If both parties reply with all the required documentation the Council will pay the rent deposit direct to the landlord.
Activating a housing register account
- The Council requires a range of documentation from an applicant to assess a housing register application and check the applicant is eligible to join the housing register. Where an applicant has changed their name by deed poll, they must provide a copy of the deed poll document or legal evidence confirming the name change. The Council cannot activate a housing register account without that evidence.
Complaints
- Where a complainant asks the Council to escalate their complaint after receiving an initial response the Council should issue a reply within 20 working days.
Was there fault by the Council
- The Council failed to progress the homelessness application when it was received on 31 October 2024. The Council accepts that when the case with the Triage Officer they should have marked it as “homeless tonight” so it would have been assessed as a priority. At the very latest that should have happened by 7 November. Instead, action was only taken on the case after further contact from the Probation Service on 14 November. Had the delay not occurred the Council would have been in a position to place Mr D in interim accommodation by 8 November at the latest. Its failure to follow the correct process meant Mr D had to wait an additional seven days during which he remained rough sleeping.
- There is fault in how the Council dealt with safeguarding concerns after it received notification of Mr D’s allegations about a sexual assault in his temporary accommodation. The Council was notified on 7 February and ASC opened a case. However, ASC failed to contact the Housing Service until a week later on 14 February. At that point it did not give details of the alleged incident or safeguarding concerns raised in relation the Council funded accommodation. It was only on 20 February that ASC made it clear to the Housing Service what the concerns were. The Council accepts this was an error on its part. It says it overlooked the need to notify Housing Services when the initial report was received and apologises. It also accepts the 14 February email failed to clarify the safeguarding concerns. This fault by the Council meant Housing Services were not fully appraised of the incident until 20 February. Once it was aware it took prompt action to move Mr D.
- The Council’s initial complaint response on 17 June 2025 incorrectly stated it was first notified about the assault on 20 February. In fact, the Council had been made aware of the incident on 7 February. It should have ensured its response, particularly about such a sensitive matter, was accurate. I also see Mr D requested the Council escalate his complaint on 9 July, but he did not receive a substantive response until 20 November, which was a delay of around three months.
- I have not found fault in the Council’s placement of Mr D into the various accommodation he was provided with. That is because on each occasion the Council followed the correct process and completed a suitability assessment. I appreciate that Mr D may disagree with the decisions taken by the Council, but the evidence shows the correct process was adhered to. The Ombudsman is not an appeal body. This means we do not take a second look at a decision to decide if it was wrong. Instead, we look at the processes an organisation followed to make its decision. If we consider it followed those processes correctly, we cannot question whether the decision was right or wrong.
- Mr D says he did not receive a copy of the PHP. I have not found fault by the Council because the evidence shows a copy of the PHP was emailed to the correct email address for Mr D on 4 December 2024. However, I do consider the PHP could and should have been sent to Mr D sooner, ideally around the time the relief duty was accepted in November.
- Mr D complains the Council did not assist him with a rent deposit to secure a private sector tenancy. The PHP sent to Mr D on 4 December 2024 explained about the rent deposit scheme. Mr D contacted the Council on 20 May 2025 asking about the scheme but did not state he had identified a property he wanted assistance with. On 10 June the Council explained to Mr D about the scheme. The Council also contacted Mr D on 9 July asking him/ his representative for information about a property he had identified so it could assess his application. The Council says it did not receive the information it needed. On 20 November the Council confirmed to Mr D that if he sent in the outstanding information, it would assess his request. Having considered the evidence, I do not see there is fault by the Council. It asked Mr D for information to assess his application but this was not received. The Council cannot provide financial assistance with rent until it is satisfied it has evidence about the suitability and sustainability of the proposed tenancy.
- In May 2025 it was apparent to the Council that Mr D may have previously changed his surname. On 19 May an Officer asked Mr D for a copy of the deed poll certificate which was needed to verify his identity. The same Officer subsequently offered to help Mr D if he found it difficult to obtain a copy. Mr D did not take up that offer of assistance and did not provide the evidence needed by the Council. The Council reiterated the importance of the documentation twice in June and that Mr D’s housing register account could not be activated until he provided the deed poll documentation. There is no fault by the Council in this matter. It followed the correct process, advised Mr D what he needed to provide and offered to assist him. Unfortunately, without receipt of the deed poll documentation the Council cannot activate a housing register account.
Did the fault cause an injustice
- The faults by the Council meant Mr D was left rough sleeping for seven days longer than necessary in 2024. He also remained at the property where an alleged assault occurred until 21 February 2025. Had the fault not occurred it is more likely than not that Mr D would have been relocated to alternative accommodation by 8 February and would not have spent a further 13 days at the property.
- In his complaint Mr D’s representative asked for compensation for the damage to Mr D’s mental health. The Ombudsman provides remedies for injustice, not compensation, punishment or fines. Our focus is on restoring services that have been denied and taking practical steps to put things right alongside service improvements to prevent similar faults happening again. In some cases, it is appropriate to ask for redress for the complainant. Where that redress takes the form of a payment, it is often a modest amount whose value is intended to be largely symbolic, rather than purely financial. It is not our role to assess economic losses or award compensation, and we direct people to the courts where that is their primary goal.
Action
- The Council has agreed to:
- Pay Mr D £200 for the avoidable seven days spent rough sleeping
- Pay Mr D £500 for the distress caused by failing to move him sooner in February 2025
- Contact Mr D to discuss his current housing situation, explain what assistance it will provide and advise on his housing options
- The Council has made a service improvement because of this case by reminding ASC officers to share safeguarding concerns promptly with partner services.
- The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above actions within four weeks of this case closing.
Decision
- I find fault causing injustice.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman