Ashford Borough Council (25 019 136)

Category : Housing > Homelessness

Decision : Upheld

Decision date : 04 Oct 2026

The Ombudsman's final decision:

Summary: Miss X complained about the Council’s handling of her requests for assistance when she was trying to flee domestic abuse. We found fault with the Council’s consideration of its homelessness duties, its approach to refuge accommodation, its application of its housing allocations policy, and the information it provided about when Miss X could approach the Ombudsman. These faults caused Miss X significant avoidable distress and uncertainty, meant she remained in accommodation where she was at risk of domestic abuse, influenced her decision to move to a refuge and change her children’s schools, and caused her to lose the opportunity to be appropriately housed sooner. The Council has agreed to apologise, make a payment to Miss X and take steps to improve its service.

The complaint

  1. Miss X complained about the Council's handling of her requests for assistance when she was trying to flee domestic abuse. She says the Council:
      1. told her that any temporary accommodation offered would be unsuitable for her and her children;
      2. advised her to move into a refuge, explaining that she would then qualify for Band B housing priority;
      3. failed to offer her interim accommodation when she later fled the abuse, instead telling her to wait until a refuge space became available;
      4. closed her homelessness application after she moved into a refuge;
      5. told her she could make a new homelessness application when she asked to leave the refuge; and
      6. alternatively advised her to seek assistance from the council in the area where she had relocated.
  2. Miss X says the Council's advice forced her to leave the area, resulting in her children having to change schools and placing her employment at risk, with the possibility of losing her job.

Back to top

The Ombudsman’s role and powers

  1. We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
  2. When considering complaints we make findings based on the balance of probabilities. This means that we look at the available relevant evidence and decide what was more likely to have happened.
  3. If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)

Back to top

How I considered this complaint

  1. I considered evidence provided by Miss X and the Council as well as relevant law, policy and guidance.
  2. Miss X and the Council had an opportunity to comment on my draft decision. I considered any comments before making a final decision.

Back to top

What I found

Relevant law and guidance

Homelessness

Legislation and statutory guidance

  1. Part 7 of the Housing Act 1996 and the Homelessness Code of Guidance for Local Authorities set out councils’ powers and duties to people who are homeless or threatened with homelessness.

Homeless definition

  1. Someone is homeless if they have no accommodation or if they have accommodation, but it is not reasonable for them to continue to live there. (Housing Act 1996, Section 175)
  2. It is not reasonable for a person to continue to live in accommodation if it is probable this will lead to violence or domestic abuse against them. (Housing Act 1996, Section 177)

Threatened with homelessness – definition

  1. Someone is threatened with homelessness if, when asking for assistance from the council on or after 3 April 2018:
  • they are likely to become homeless within 56 days; or
  • they have been served with a valid Section 21 notice which will expire within 56 days. (Housing Act 1996, section 175(4) & (5)

The prevention duty

  1. If a council is satisfied an applicant is threatened with homelessness and eligible for assistance, it must take steps to help the applicant keep their home or find somewhere new to live. In deciding what steps to take, a council must have regard to its assessment of the applicant’s case. (Housing Act 1996, section 195)

The relief duty

  1. Councils must take reasonable steps to help to secure suitable accommodation for any eligible homeless person. When a council decides this duty has come to an end, it must notify the applicant in writing (Housing Act 1996, section 189B)

Applications

  1. If someone contacts a council seeking accommodation or help to obtain accommodation and gives ‘reason to believe’ they ‘may be’ homeless or threatened with homelessness within 56 days, the council has a duty to make inquiries into what, if any, further duty it owes them. The threshold for triggering the duty to make inquiries is low. The person does not have to complete a specific form or approach a particular department of the council. (Housing Act 1996, section 184 and Homelessness Code of Guidance paragraphs 6.2 and 18.5)

Gatekeeping/homelessness prevention

  1. Councils can suggest alternative solutions in cases of potential homelessness where these would be suitable and acceptable to the applicant. However councils must not do this to avoid their legal duties, especially the duty to make inquiries into the applicant’s homelessness. The Ombudsman has criticised councils for ‘gatekeeping’ practices, for example, failing to take a homelessness application at the earliest opportunity.

Duty to arrange interim accommodation (section 188)

  1. A council must secure interim accommodation for an applicant and their household if it has reason to believe the applicant may be homeless, eligible for assistance and have a priority need. (Housing Act 1996, section 188)

Priority need

  1. Examples of applicants in priority need are:
  • people with dependent children; and
  • victims of domestic abuse.

Use of refuges

  1. Refuges provide short-term, intensive support for people fleeing abuse. The Code makes clear that due to the intensity of the support while in a refuge, they are not simply a substitute for other forms of temporary accommodation. Councils should work with the refuge provider to consider how long the person needs to stay before other accommodation is provided. (Homelessness Code of Guidance, Chapter 21)

DASH assessment

  1. A Domestic Abuse, Stalking & Honour-based Violence (DASH) assessment may be carried out to assess the risks to a victim and the action needed to protect them. This is a standardised assessment, which produces a score out of 24. A score above 14 should result in a Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Conference (MARAC) referral, although the person carrying out the assessment may make a referral where the score is lower if they have serious concerns about the victim’s safety.

Suitability of accommodation

  1. The law says councils must ensure all accommodation provided to homeless applicants is suitable for the needs of the applicant and members of their household. This duty applies to interim accommodation and accommodation provided under the main housing duty. (Housing Act 1996, section 206 and Homelessness Code of Guidance 17.2)
  2. Homelessness temporary accommodation must be legally suitable. (Housing Act 1996, section 206) Anyone who believes their temporary accommodation is unsuitable can ask the Council to review the accommodation’s suitability. (Housing Act 1996, section 202) If the Council’s review decides the accommodation is unsuitable, the Council must provide suitable accommodation. If the review decides the accommodation is suitable, the applicant has the right to appeal to the county court on a point of law. (Housing Act 1996, section 204)
  3. Councils must consider the location of accommodation when they consider if it is suitable for the applicant and members of their household. If a council places an applicant outside its district, it must consider, among other matters:
  • the distance of the accommodation from the “home” district;
  • the significance of any disruption to the education of members of the applicant’s household; and
  • the proximity and accessibility to local services, amenities and transport. (Homelessness (Suitability of Accommodation) Order 2012)
  1. Wherever possible, Councils should avoid using bed and breakfast accommodation. (Homelessness Code of Guidance paragraph 17.33)
  2. Bed and breakfast (B&B) accommodation can only be used for households which include a pregnant woman or dependent child when no other accommodation is available and then for no more than six weeks. B&B is accommodation which is not self-contained, not owned or managed by the council or a registered provider of social housing and where the toilet, washing, or cooking facilities are shared with other households. (Homelessness (Suitability of Accommodation) (England) Order 2003 and Homelessness Code of Guidance paragraph 17.36-17.37)

Housing allocations

The published scheme

  1. Every local housing authority must publish an allocations scheme that sets out how it prioritises applicants, and its procedures for allocating housing. All allocations must be made in strict accordance with the published scheme. (Housing Act 1996, section 166A(1) & (14))

Council’s housing allocations policy

  1. The Council’s housing allocations policy in place until April 2026 placed applicants into priority bands from Band A, the highest priority, to Band E, the lowest. As far as is relevant to this complaint, applicants owed a prevention or relief duty under Part 7 of the Housing Act 1996, or who were lacking one bedroom or sharing basic facilities, would generally be placed in Band C. However, the policy also provided that where domestic abuse had been established, the victim was unable to return home and no other housing options were available, the applicant would be awarded Band A.
  2. In April 2026, the Council introduced a new allocations policy. This included Band H for homeless households and Bands A to C for other levels of housing need.

What happened

  1. Miss X contacted the Council and explained that she was fleeing domestic abuse with her children. The Council says she told it that her ex-partner would become angry if he knew she was looking for alternative accommodation and asked the Council to arrange contact with her in advance.
  2. The Council arranged an appointment with Miss X six days later. At that appointment, three options were discussed: a planned move into privately rented accommodation, moving into a refuge outside the Council’s area, or accepting interim accommodation.
  3. The Council’s notes record that it advised Miss X that interim accommodation would not be an ideal option, that homelessness should be a last resort and that any accommodation offered was likely to be outside the Council’s area. Miss X explained that she worked within the Council’s area and that her children attended school there, so moving out of the area would disrupt her employment and their education.
  4. The Council accepted the prevention duty and issued a Personalised Housing Plan. It also completed a DASH risk assessment, which assessed Miss X as being at medium risk. The Council’s records indicate that a planned move into private rented accommodation was the preferred option because it would allow Miss X to remain in the area with her children and continue working. The Council also arranged an appointment for Miss X to discuss refuge accommodation.
  5. After speaking with a refuge, Miss X told the Council that she was concerned that moving into a refuge would mean giving up her employment. She also said she had been looking for privately rented accommodation but had not found anything suitable.
  6. About a week later, Miss X told the Council that she intended to move into a refuge as the alterative interim accommodation was likely to be outside the Council’s area and because of concerns about the other people who might be accommodated there.
  7. The following week, Miss X told the Council that she had been offered a place in a refuge. She said she would take her children out of school to accept the placement but wanted to remain on the Council’s housing register. The Council told her that she was currently in Band C and that she would be moved to Band B once it received a nomination from the refuge.
  8. The Council subsequently ended its prevention duty as she had moved into the refuge.
  9. In October, the Council made Miss X’s housing register account live so she could bid for properties. It maintained her Band C priority on the basis that she was sharing facilities and lacked one bedroom. The Council told her she could not be placed in Band B because the refuge was outside its area. It also told her that she could make a new homelessness application when her licence at the refuge ended.
  10. Miss X challenged this. She referred the Council to its allocations policy, which allocated Band A where domestic abuse had been established, the victim could not return home and there were no other housing options. She also questioned why this had not applied when she had fled her home and living in accommodation without water or electricity while waiting for a refuge placement.
  11. Miss X also contacted her local MP. She explained that she had been advised against temporary accommodation as it was likely she would hear abuse take place and have her children around drug users, and that she should instead seek refuge accommodation. She said she had subsequently moved into unsuitable accommodation for more than a week while waiting for a refuge place. She also said she had understood that moving into the refuge would result in increased housing priority but was later told she would need to make another homelessness application when the refuge placement ended.
  12. The MP referred Miss X’s concerns to the Council and asked it to review the matter. Miss X subsequently complained to the Council about the advice she had received, the decision to close her homelessness application, and the housing priority she had been given.
  13. In its response to the MP, the Council said it had applied the correct legislation and had awarded Miss X the correct band. It said Miss X had independently chosen to enter the refuge and had not been directed there by the housing officer. It apologised for any confusion about the banding but said Miss X was not eligible for Band B because the refuge was outside the Council’s area.
  14. When the Council responded to Miss X’s complaint it accepted the housing officer had provided Miss X with incorrect information about Band B and apologised. It maintained that Band C was the correct priority under its policy. It also said that moving into the refuge had been Miss X’s decision and that, had she instead accepted temporary accommodation from the Council, she would have remained in Band C. It therefore considered she had not been disadvantaged by the incorrect advice.
  15. Miss X escalated her complaint. She provided an email from a social worker in the Council’s children’s services team who said they had been present during the appointment with the housing officer. The social worker said the housing officer had explained that interim accommodation was not considered suitable for a young family fleeing domestic abuse because the available accommodation was occupied by single men, some of whom had caused disturbances requiring police involvement and advised against placing Miss X and her children in that environment. The social worker also recalled being told that children could no longer be accommodated in bed and breakfast accommodation and that Miss X should therefore seek refuge accommodation.
  16. The next month, the Council issued its final complaint response. It said that households may be placed in temporary accommodation which is suitable only in the short term in an emergency. It said it tried to ensure women fleeing domestic abuse were accommodated away from anti-social behaviour and single men, but this was not always possible. It also said it could not always know who else would be accommodated in a property. The Council confirmed that children could not be placed in bed and breakfast accommodation unless there was no other available accommodation and said that this could mean families being placed outside the area. It said this information had been provided to Miss X to be transparent about the possible consequences of accepting temporary accommodation and was not intended to discourage her from doing so. However, the Council accepted that Miss X had been given incorrect information which was part of the reason why she moved into a refuge.
  17. Later, the Council carried out stage one and stage two reviews of Miss X’s housing register priority. Both reviews concluded that she had been correctly assessed as Band C under the policy then in force.
  18. In April 2026, the Council introduced its new housing allocations policy and reassessed applicants on the housing register. The Council assessed her as Band A because she was fleeing domestic abuse and had a local connection. The Council subsequently offered her housing.
  19. In response to my enquiries, the Council said it did not offer Miss X interim accommodation when she first approached because she had asked for matters to be dealt with in a planned way.
  20. The Council said it accepted the prevention duty because, at that point, Miss X could still occupy her accommodation and there was a real prospect that she would have to leave within 56 days. It said it ended that duty after she moved into the refuge because it considered the refuge to be suitable accommodation available to her for at least six months.
  21. The Council said it had no evidence that Miss X had told it she was living in alternative unsuitable accommodation. I have therefore considered the evidence on this point separately from the Council’s handling of her homelessness situation.
  22. The Council also said that people moving into a refuge are given the option of keeping their housing application open or closing it. It said Miss X remained on the housing register after the prevention duty ended.

My findings

The Council’s response when Miss X sought help

  1. When Miss X first approached the Council, it had reason to believe she may be homeless or threatened with homelessness, was eligible for assistance and may have been in priority need. The threshold for this is low and does not require a full homelessness assessment before the interim accommodation duty arises.
  2. The Council had a duty under section 188 to provide interim accommodation if it had reason to believe Miss X was homeless, eligible and in priority need. Miss X had dependent children and was fleeing domestic abuse. The Council did not provide interim accommodation or properly consider whether it should do so. Instead, it arranged an assessment six days after she first contacted it. Miss X’s preference for a planned approach did not remove the Council’s duty. This was fault.
  3. The Council accepted a prevention duty because it considered Miss X could occupy her existing accommodation and was therefore not homeless. However, section 177 of the Housing Act 1996 states accommodation is not reasonable to continue to occupy where it is probable that this will lead to violence or domestic abuse. The Council knew Miss X was fleeing domestic abuse and had completed a DASH assessment. It should therefore have properly considered whether it was reasonable for her to remain in the property.
  4. There is no evidence the Council properly considered section 177 in reaching its view that Miss X could remain at the property. Instead, it treated her as threatened with homelessness because she could continue to occupy the accommodation. This was fault.
  5. The Council presented interim accommodation as undesirable, a last resort and likely to be outside its area. The social worker’s evidence is that the Council officer also said interim accommodation would be unsuitable for a young family because of other occupants and advised Miss X to use a refuge instead.
  6. Councils can discuss alternative options with applicants, but they should not use those alternatives to avoid or delay their statutory duties. In this case, the Council’s advice discouraged Miss X from pursuing interim accommodation and directed her towards refuge accommodation without properly determining whether she was entitled to interim accommodation. This amounted to gatekeeping and was fault.
  7. The Council was correct that families with children can only be placed in B&B accommodation in limited circumstances. However, this did not mean that interim accommodation was unavailable or that a refuge was the only option. The way the information was presented gave Miss X the impression that the Council could not provide suitable interim accommodation. This was misleading and was fault.

Advice about refuge and housing priority

  1. The Council accepts that Miss X was incorrectly told she would receive Band B priority once she entered the refuge. The information given to her was wrong and material to her decision-making. The Council accepts that its advice influenced her decision, and I find that the inaccurate and misleading advice was fault.
  2. I do not consider Miss X’s decision to enter the refuge was entirely independent and informed. Her decision was influenced by the Council’s advice about the availability and suitability of interim accommodation and the housing priority she would receive if she entered a refuge.
  3. I cannot say, even on the balance of probabilities, that Miss X would have accepted interim accommodation or remained in the Council’s area if she had been given correct advice. However, the Council’s advice deprived her of the opportunity to make that decision with accurate information. It contributed to her children changing schools and moving to a refuge outside the area, with consequent effects on their education and her employment.
  4. There is no evidence the Council knew Miss X was living in alternative unsuitable accommodation when she did. I therefore do not find fault with the Council for failing to provide assistance at that point. This does not alter my finding about the Council’s earlier failure to properly consider interim accommodation.

The Council’s handling of Miss X’s homelessness after she entered the refuge

  1. The Council ended the prevention duty after Miss X moved into the refuge because it considered the refuge to be suitable accommodation available to her for at least six months. However, the Homelessness Code of Guidance makes clear that refuges are not simply a substitute for other forms of temporary accommodation. Councils should work with refuge providers to consider how long a person needs to remain there before other accommodation is provided.
  2. There is no evidence the Council properly considered this guidance or worked with the refuge provider to establish how long Miss X needed to remain there before other accommodation should be secured. Instead, it treated the refuge as accommodation available to Miss X for at least six months and ended its prevention duty on that basis. This was fault.
  3. The Council’s advice that Miss X could make a new homelessness application when her refuge licence ended was also problematic. It should have clearly explained the basis on which her existing duty was ending and what assistance remained available, rather than giving the impression that she would need to start the homelessness process again.

Miss X’s housing register priority

  1. The Council's previous allocations policy awarded Band A where domestic abuse had been established, the victim could not return home, and no other housing options were available. Miss X's circumstances were consistent with these criteria. The Council knew she was fleeing domestic abuse, she could not safely return to her former home, and the evidence shows she had been unable to secure suitable private rented accommodation.
  2. The Council nevertheless kept her in Band C. It subsequently reviewed this decision at both stage one and stage two and concluded that Band C was correct. I accept that the Council was required to apply the policy in effect at the time and that reporting domestic abuse did not automatically mean an applicant qualified for Band A. However, I have seen no evidence that the Council properly considered whether Miss X met the specific Band A criteria or adequately explained why she did not.
  3. This is particularly concerning because, following the introduction of the new allocations policy in April 2026, the Council reassessed Miss X and awarded Band A on the basis that she was fleeing domestic abuse and had a local connection. I have seen no evidence of a material change in Miss X's circumstances which explains why she did not meet the relevant domestic abuse criteria under the previous policy but did meet them under the new one.
  4. I therefore find the Council was at fault in failing to properly recognise and apply the domestic abuse provision in its previous allocations policy. The fact that two subsequent reviews upheld the Band C decision does not remove the underlying fault. Rather, it meant the Council repeated the error when it reviewed Miss X's housing priority and considered the complaints from her and the MP.

The Council’s signposting to the Ombudsman

  1. The Council correctly signposted Miss X to the Ombudsman in its stage two complaint response. However, it incorrectly stated that the Ombudsman could not consider her complaint until 12 weeks after the Council’s stage two response. This was not correct.
  2. The Ombudsman’s guidance allows a person to bring a complaint to us once they have received the organisation’s final response. The reference to 12 weeks relates to the period we generally considered reasonable for an organisation to respond to a complaint where a person had not yet received a response. It did not mean that a complainant had to wait 12 weeks after receiving a final response before approaching the Ombudsman. The guidance has since been amended, and the equivalent period is now 16 weeks.
  3. The Council therefore gave Miss X incorrect information about when she could bring her complaint to the Ombudsman. This was fault and is significant because our ability to investigate complaints can be affected by the passage of time, including whether matters fall outside the period we would normally consider. However, Miss X did bring her complaint to us without delay, so I find no injustice was caused.

Conclusion

  1. The Council failed to properly consider whether Miss X was homeless and entitled to interim accommodation; discouraged her from pursuing interim accommodation and effectively gatekept her access to the homelessness process; gave her misleading information about the suitability and availability of temporary accommodation; gave her incorrect information about the housing priority she would receive if she moved into a refuge; ended its prevention duty without properly applying the guidance about refuges; and failed to properly apply its own domestic abuse housing allocation criteria.
  2. These faults caused Miss X significant avoidable uncertainty and distress. The Council’s inaccurate and misleading advice materially affected the choices available to her. She remained in a property with her ex-partner where she was at risk of harm for three weeks. She moved her children out of their school and into a refuge outside the Council's area, with consequent disruption to their education and potential impact on her employment. I cannot conclude that these consequences would necessarily have been avoided if the Council had acted without fault, but the Council's failures deprived Miss X of the opportunity to make informed decisions about her family's accommodation and housing options.
  3. I also consider that, had the Council correctly awarded Miss X Band A priority when she was first assessed, she would have been in a position to secure suitable housing sooner than she ultimately did. However, there is insufficient evidence for me to determine when she would have been offered suitable accommodation.
  4. The Council ultimately awarded Miss X Band A under its new policy and provided her with housing. However, this does not remedy the injustice caused by the earlier failures.

Back to top

Action

  1. To remedy the injustice caused by the above faults, within four weeks of the date of our final decision, the Council has agreed to:
    • apologise to Miss X in line with our guidance on Making an effective apology;
    • pay Miss X £300 to recognise the three weeks she remained in a property where she was at risk of harm;
    • pay Miss X £700 to recognise the significant avoidable distress, uncertainty and loss of opportunity caused by the Council’s handling of her homelessness and housing situation; and
    • review its guidance and templates for complaint responses to ensure complainants are given accurate information about their right to approach the Ombudsman.
  2. Within three months of the date of my final decision, the Council has agreed to provide training and/or guidance to all relevant staff on:
        1. the duty to arrange interim accommodation where there is reason to believe an applicant may be homeless, eligible and in priority need, and the need to ensure applicants are not discouraged from seeking interim accommodation;
        2. sections 175, 177 and 188 of the Housing Act 1996, including their application where an applicant is fleeing domestic abuse;
        3. the relationship between refuge accommodation and the Council’s statutory homelessness duties, including the need to properly consider the guidance on working with refuge providers to secure suitable accommodation; and
        4. the relevant domestic abuse provisions in the Council’s housing allocations policy and their application when assessing an applicant’s housing priority.
  3. The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above actions.

Back to top

Decision

  1. I find fault causing injustice. The Council has agreed actions to remedy injustice.

Back to top

Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman

Print this page

LGO logogram

Review your privacy settings

Required cookies

These cookies enable the website to function properly. You can only disable these by changing your browser preferences, but this will affect how the website performs.

View required cookies

Analytical cookies

Google Analytics cookies help us improve the performance of the website by understanding how visitors use the site.
We recommend you set these 'ON'.

View analytical cookies

In using Google Analytics, we do not collect or store personal information that could identify you (for example your name or address). We do not allow Google to use or share our analytics data. Google has developed a tool to help you opt out of Google Analytics cookies.

Privacy settings