Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea (25 021 479)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: Miss B complained that the Council’s failed to progress her housing application and to deal properly with her complaints of noise nuisance. We found the Council at fault for failing to progress her housing application. The Council has already offered Miss B a housing appointment. It has also agreed to apologise to her and make a symbolic payment.
The complaint
- Miss B complained that the Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea (the Council):
- failed to deal with her housing application submitted in January 2025;
- failed to respond properly to her complaints of noise nuisance from a neighbour;
- disclosed her identity to the alleged perpetrator;
- gave an inaccurate account of the visit;
- incorrectly refused to consider an Anti-Social Behaviour Community Trigger;
- failed to properly consider a safeguarding referral; and
- failed to deal with her complaints properly or in a timely manner.
- Miss B said the ongoing situation has caused her significant distress and the data breach put her at risk of harm.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
- If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
How I considered this complaint
- I considered evidence provided by Miss B and the Council as well as relevant law, policy and guidance.
- Miss B and the Council had an opportunity to comment on my draft decision. I considered any comments before making a final decision.
What I found
Statutory nuisances
- Under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 (EPA), councils have a duty to take reasonable steps to investigate potential ‘statutory nuisances’.
- Activities a council might decide are a statutory nuisance include:
- noise from premises or vehicles, equipment or machinery in the street;
- For the issue to count as a statutory nuisance, it must:
- unreasonably and substantially interfere with the use or enjoyment of a home or other property; and/or
- injure health or be likely to injure health.
- There is no fixed point at which something becomes a statutory nuisance. Councils rely on suitably qualified officers to gather evidence. Officers may, for example, ask the complainant to complete diary sheets, fit noise-monitoring equipment, or make site visits. Councils will sometimes offer an ‘out-of-hours’ service for people to contact, if a nuisance occurs outside normal working time.
- Once evidence gathering is complete, a council will assess the evidence. It will consider matters such as the timing, duration, and intensity of the alleged nuisance. Officers will use their professional judgement to decide whether a statutory nuisance exists.
- The law says that a potential nuisance must be judged on how it affects the average person. Councils cannot take action to stop something which is only a nuisance to the complainant because they have special circumstances, such as a medical condition which makes them unusually sensitive to noise or fumes.
The Anti-social Behaviour Case Review (formerly known as the Community Trigger)
- The Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014 introduced a way to review the handling of complaints of anti-social behaviour (ASB). This is the anti-social behaviour case review, which was previously known as the ‘Community Trigger’.
- When a person asks for a review, relevant bodies (which may include the council, police and others) should decide whether it meets the local threshold. Relevant local bodies should agree their review threshold, but the ASB statutory guidance says this should be, at a maximum, that a complainant has made three reports of ASB within six months.
- If the threshold is met, the relevant bodies should carry out the review. They should share information, consider what action has already been taken, decide whether more should be done, and then tell the complainant the outcome. If they decide to take more action, they should create an action plan.
Homelessness
- Someone is homeless if they have no accommodation or if they have accommodation, but it is not reasonable for them to continue to live there. (Housing Act 1996, Section 175)
Housing allocations
- Every local housing authority must publish an allocations scheme that sets out how it prioritises applicants, and its procedures for allocating housing. All allocations must be made in strict accordance with the published scheme. (Housing Act 1996, section 166A(1) & (14))
Reasonable preference
- An allocations scheme must give reasonable preference to applicants in the following categories:
- homeless people;
- people in insanitary, overcrowded or unsatisfactory housing;
- people who need to move on medical or welfare grounds;
- people who need to move to avoid hardship to themselves or others;
(Housing Act 1996, section 166A(3))
Council complaint procedure
- The Council has a two stage corporate complaints procedure. It says it aims to respond to stage one complaints within 10 working days, but complex cases may take up to 20. At stage two it aims to respond within 20 working days.
What happened
Background
- Miss B first approached the Council in November 2022 asking to move due to the behaviour of her neighbours and the impact on her health. She completed a medical assessment form, but the Council did not award her any priority. She had also complained to her landlord, a housing association, about mould in the property and said it was impacting her health.
2024 onwards
- In late 2024 Miss B submitted a housing application to the Council saying she wished to move due to issues with the type of housing she lived: it was aimed at residents with mental health issues. She also raised the disrepair. The Council booked a telephone appointment with her and discussed the possibility of helping her to find accommodation elsewhere.
- The Council held an initial telephone appointment with her in mid-January 2025. The caseworker followed this up with an email saying he would pursue a medical assessment. He would also discuss with colleagues to see if it was possible to move her due to her current accommodation being ‘valuable’. It also said it would refer her to another organisation who could possibly provide supported accommodation in a different area. They also suggested she registered on the Homefinder scheme.
- In February 2025 Miss B’s GP wrote a letter of support for her housing application. It said her physical and mental health was affected by the mould and her neighbours. In March 2025 her social prescriber helped her to complete a medical assessment form in which she described how the mould affected her health. She also referred to issues with previous neighbours who were no longer in the property. Miss B said she did not send this back to the Council due to her anxiety.
- In April 2025 Miss B started to receive help from an adviser at the housing charity Shelter. He tried to contact the Council to find out what was happening with Miss B’s housing application. He said the previous caseworker was on long-term sick leave. In July 2025 he emailed the Council suggesting a tenancy swap or a management transfer through the housing association.
- In August 2025 the adviser emailed Miss B saying the Council was considering four options: Homeswap, supported housing through another organisation, a medical assessment or a management transfer.
- On 8 October Miss B confirmed she would like a referral to the supported housing scheme.
- On 14 October 2025 Miss B reported to the Council that a neighbour was playing loud music late at night, along with screaming and shouting and banging doors. An Environmental Health Officer (EHO) contacted Miss B 30 minutes later to discuss the noise. Miss B confirmed the noise had stopped but it had been a problem for a while and was more intense at the weekends. She said she wished to remain anonymous. The EHO advised her to report the noise if it started again.
- The following evening, she reported loud music again and said the police had visited twice the previous day. An EHO called within 15 minutes, but Miss B said the noise had died down. The EHO notes of the call say that the officer offered to drive by to see if they could witness the noise and then contact the relevant parties. The notes said Miss B said that if the officer wished to witness the noise in her property, they should buzz her doors she could let them into the block. Miss B denies she was offered this opportunity.
- Approximately an hour later the EHO drove past the property and called Miss B but there was no answer. They did not hear any loud music coming from the property. Miss B rang back and said the noise had stopped but she expected it to start up again shortly. About 40 minutes later Miss B reported that the music had started again along with loud banging. The EHO agreed to visit again. Miss B said that was fine, but she asked the EHO to ensure they did not alert the perpetrator to their arrival.
- The EHO arrived at the property over an hour later, as the previous call out had taken some time to deal with. On arrival they telephoned Miss B to gain access to the building. They went up to the flat where they believed Miss B lived but said the occupant denied any knowledge of making a noise complaint.
- They located a different flat and the resident let them in. However, the EHO realised this was the alleged perpetrator and left the flat. They had concerns about their safety in the flat. The EHO said there was low-level music playing but it the volume was reasonable and it was extremely unlikely to constitute a statutory nuisance. The EHO telephoned Miss B again but they said Miss B refused to confirm which flat she lived in and said the EHOs should be able to hear the noise from outside. The EHO said they expressed frustration at this point and said that in order to investigate the noise in any meaningful way they would need to access the property to witness the alleged noise.
- Miss B emailed her Shelter adviser after the visit confirming she did not let the EHO in as she was scared she would be identified due to the fact he had said her name in the corridor.
- Miss B complained to the Council the following day saying that the previous evening an EHO had come out to witness the noise from her neighbour. She said the EHO wanted to come into her property which she was not expecting and while discussing this the EHO loudly said he name in the communal hall. Miss B was afraid the perpetrator heard this and feared she is at risk of attack from her neighbour who she believed had mental health issues. She requested a move to a different property.
- The next day Miss B made a further complaint as she discovered no action had been taken on her housing application since January 2025. She also raised the potential data breach again and said she feared for her life.
- The Council acknowledged the complaints and said they would be investigated together.
- On 20 October Miss B submitted a request for an anti-social behaviour case review reporting three incidents of noise nuisance. The Council said the threshold for this was not met as the three incidents had occurred over a two-day period and did not meet the statutory requirements. The Council said it had carried out a review and discussed the case with partner agencies.
- On 21 October, Shelter closed her case. The adviser said that her circumstances were very unlikely to warrant a management transfer through the Council as these were only approved in very exceptional circumstances, such as domestic abuse, severe harassment or witness protection.
- On 23 October Miss B reported noise nuisance to the police. They booked a video call appointment but did not manage to talk to Miss B. She requested they did not visit as she wished to maintain her anonymity.
- Miss B also contacted the Council to request a safeguarding intervention due to the significant distress she was experiencing from her neighbour and her vulnerability. A safeguarding manager spoke to Miss B on 27 October to better understand her situation. Miss B said she was experiencing disturbance from loud music being played late at night by a neighbour, but it was being addressed through anti-social behaviour and housing management processes. The Council held a professionals meeting but neither the perpetrator or Miss B were known to any services. It also discussed the case with the housing and anti-social behaviour teams and contacted Miss B’s landlord who also agreed to contact Miss B to offer assistance.
- The Council did not instigate a safeguarding inquiry as it concluded the statutory criteria were not met: Miss B’s concerns related to noise nuisance and neighbour disputes rather than neglect or abuse. It also had not identified any unmet care or support needs arising from the situation.
- On 6 November the Council responded to her complaints at stage one of the complaints procedure. It upheld her complaint about the failure to progress her housing application. It apologised and said it had referred the case to a service manager who would contact her within the next week.
- It did not uphold the complaint about the noise nuisance. It said Miss B had complained six times over two days about noise from a neighbour’s flat. Officers responded within 30 minutes on each occasion. The Council detailed the version of events contained in the EHO’s records and said the officer considered Miss B had given inaccurate information about where she lived and had refused entry to her flat. They also said the officers had not witnessed any noise nuisance from the alleged perpetrator’s flat. The officer concerned said that it had been necessary to confirm her address to properly investigate the complaint and if any part of the call had been heard by the perpetrator It would have been accidental.
- Miss B escalated her complaint the following day. She disagreed with the EHO’s version of events. She said the EHO had agreed to investigate the issue from the communal areas to maintain her anonymity. She said the EHO’s use of her name was neither accidental or unintentional and they had shouted it in the communal hallway. She said the officer who had knocked on her door was walking away when she answered and said ‘sorry, wrong door’. She said she no longer felt able to report noise nuisance and had kept her own diary for the past three weeks. She wanted a direct offer of a home outside the borough and substantial compensation.
- On 21 November Miss B added a complaint about the failure to proceed to an anti-social behaviour case review and the fact the Council had telephoned her landlord.
- The Council responded to the complaint at Stage 2 on 29 December, after she had already complained to us. It apologised for not contacting her as promised about the housing application and said it would do so by 28 November (a month prior to the date of the complaint response). The Council said the EHO considered the alleged perpetrator was well aware Miss B had complained before he had said her name in the communal hallway. The case did not meet the criteria for a case review, but the Council had still held a professionals meeting. Neither Miss B nor the perpetrator were known to any services, and the safeguarding threshold was not met. It said a housing officer would speak to both parties. It upheld a slight delay in responding to her stage two complaint.
- In response to my enquiries the Council accepts it has failed to progress Miss B’s housing application. It says it has no record of the actual application and the failure to contact Miss B after November 2025 was probably due to the cyber-attack against the Council around this time which prevented access to any case records.
Findings
Housing application
- The Council has accepted it has repeatedly failed to progress Miss B’s housing application made in late 2024. The records show the Council had received it by January 2025 and made an appointment to discuss it further. There are no Council records of any further action until Miss B added information about the noise nuisance in October 2025 and made a complaint. There is evidence through the Shelter adviser that he tried to make contact and progress the case between April and Augst 2025 but there is no evidence anything was decided.
- Once the Council picked up the case again in October 2025, after Miss B complained, it promised on two occasions to progress the matter but failed to do so, probably because of the cyber attack which occurred in November 2025.This failure for over a year was fault, which caused Miss B uncertainty.
- Between January and October 2025, it appears Miss B’s wish to move was due to concerns about historic incidents with neighbours who no longer lived in the block and more importantly the mould in her flat. However, Miss B did not return the medical assessment form and neither had she contacted the housing association about mould since October 2024, so her evidence for needing to move was not very strong.
- There is no evidence the Council was considering a homeless application or an application to join the housing register or that it considered her current accommodation was unsuitable for her. The mould was an issue for the housing association to resolve, not the Council. Miss B was clear she wanted to live in a different borough, and the Shelter adviser was looking at an exchange or a management transfer through the housing association. He confirmed in October 2025 that her circumstances would not warrant a management transfer through the Council.
- So even though the delay was frustrating I have not concluded she missed out on the opportunity to move, because it is unclear whether any of the options were being, or could be, pursued and some were outside the control of the Council.
- I have also considered that Miss B did not make any complaints about anti-social-behaviour or noise nuisance from her current neighbour until October 2025. So up to this point, the anti-social behaviour was not relevant to the delay in progressing her housing application.
- Even after October 2025 Miss B had only made complaint of nuisance on two consecutive days and the noise was not witnessed by officers, so again it is difficult to conclude that the outcome would have been different if the Council had contacted her about her wish to move. However, I accept the failure to progress the application at all has caused Miss B some uncertainty as to her housing situation.
Noise nuisance/anti-social behaviour
- I have not identified any fault in the way the Council initially responded on 14 and 15 October 2025 to Miss B’s complaints of noise nuisance/anti-social behaviour. The EHO contacted her promptly on each occasion and made several attempts to visit the property. They did not hear any excessive noise either inside or outside the building and did not gain access to Miss B’s property to witness the noise. While I understand Miss B’s concerns about her anonymity, the Council cannot properly investigate a complaint of noise nuisance without witnessing the noise from the affected areas, so without a visit the case is unlikely to have progressed any further.
- I cannot say which version of events is correct about the visit on the evening of 15 October. However, on the balance of probabilities, it appears Miss B did not allow the officers access to her property and was unclear about the addresses due to her concerns about anonymity, which impeded a proper investigation. It also appears the officers were confused about the address of both the alleged perpetrator and Miss B.
- I also consider on the balance of probabilities that the officer did say Miss B’s name in the communal area which was fault. But I cannot say whether this was unreasonable as I cannot conclude how loudly it was said, or exactly where it was said or what other noise was present at the time. There is also no evidence this had any impact on the behaviour of the alleged perpetrator towards Miss B (one comment she did make to Miss B’s ex-partner was not specific to Miss B) and Miss B made no further complaints about noise nuisance to the Council to allow it to investigate further. But I accept the events caused Miss B some distress.
Anti-social behaviour case review
- The Council has explained that Miss B’s case did not meet the statutory criteria of three incidents in six months to carry out a case review as the complaints were made over a two-day period. The Council has not confirmed to me that this was because the complaints only counted as two separate incidents but given that no other complaints were made before or after on any different days and the noise was not actually witnessed, I have concluded there is insufficient evidence to make a finding of fault. But it was fault not to respond properly to my enquiries to enable this point to be clarified.
Safeguarding referral
- I find no fault with the actions the Council took regarding Miss B’s safeguarding referral. It discussed the matter with Miss B, along with the relevant agencies and professionals. It did not consider Miss B had any unmet care or support needs connected to the alleged nuisance and considered that housing and anti-social behaviour teams were best placed to consider the situation.
Complaint delay
- The Council exceeded the 10-working day target at stage one by four days and the stage two 20 working day target by three weeks, but this included the Christmas period. I do not consider the delay of four days caused injustice to Mss B and the Council has apologised for the three-week delay in responding at stage two, which I consider is a sufficient remedy.
Action
- In recognition of the uncertainty caused by the failure to progress Miss B’s housing application, I recommended the Council within one month of the date of my final decision:
- offers Miss B an appointment to discuss her current housing situation; and
- apologises to Miss B and makes a symbolic payment of £150.
- The Council has already offered an appointment which Miss B has refused and has agreed to the other recommendation. The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above actions.
Decision
- I find fault causing injustice. The Council has agreed actions to remedy injustice.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman