Sheffield City Council (26 005 326)
Category : Environment and regulation > Trees
Decision : Closed after initial enquiries
Decision date : 04 Oct 2026
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: We will not investigate Mr X’s complaint about the Council’s decision not to remove or further reduce a tree it owns in the highway in front of his property. There is not enough evidence of fault in the Council’s decision-making to warrant us investigating and we cannot achieve the outcome he wants. It would be reasonable for Mr X to pursue any property damage or personal injury liability issues with the Council’s insurers and, if required, at court.
The complaint
- Mr X lives in a property with a large tree at the front in the Council’s highway. The Council agreed to prune the tree back about two metres and completed the works. Mr X complains the Council:
- has refused to prune the tree further at its expense, or remove the tree;
- has removed other similar trees in the street but not the one outside his house.
- Mr X says the tree drops branches, some of which almost hit him and his grandchild, and have hit his car. He is concerned the branches will cause damage, and says the tree roots have already damaged his driveway which the Council has not resolved. Mr X wants the Council to prune the tree back to be within the highway boundary or completely remove it.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints of injustice caused by ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. I have used the word fault to refer to these. We consider whether there was fault in the way an organisation made its decision. If there was no fault in how the organisation made its decision, we cannot question the outcome. (Local Government Act 1974, section 34(3), as amended)
- We provide a free service but must use public money carefully. We do not start or continue an investigation if we decide:
- there is not enough evidence of fault to justify investigating; or
- we cannot achieve the outcome someone wants.
(Local Government Act 1974, section 24A(6), section 34(B))
- The law says we cannot normally investigate a complaint when someone could take the matter to court. However, we may decide to investigate if we consider it would be unreasonable to expect the person to go to court. (Local Government Act 1974, section 26(6)(c), as amended)
How I considered this complaint
- I considered information from Mr X and the Council, and the Ombudsman’s Assessment Code.
My assessment
- We are not an appeal body. We may only criticise a council decision where there is evidence of fault in the decision-making process and but for that fault a different decision would have been made. So we consider the process officers have followed to make their decision. We cannot replace a decision with our own or someone else’s opinion if the decision was reached after following a proper process.
- In response to Mr X’s concerns, the Council’s officers inspected the tree. They found it in fair condition with no instability, disease or decay but decided its crown should be reduced by up to 2.5 metres and reshaped. They would then reassess the tree as part of its routine inspection process. Officers explained their approach and policy mean they do not remove healthy highway trees. The Council advised Mr X of his right to cut back any of the tree’s branches which are overhanging his property boundary, as long as he or his contractors take reasonable care not to damage the tree or make it unstable. Officers said the Council would not cut back overhanging branches unless they were close to buildings. They advised Mr X that if he wanted to have the tree pruned, he may fund this work to be done by an agreed, accredited and insured contractor.
- Officers gathered and took account of relevant information about the tree’s condition and location to reach their decision about the works to do to it under the Council’s policy. That is a professional judgement decision officers were entitled to make. There is not enough evidence of fault in the Council’s decision-making process here to warrant us investigating. We recognise Mr X may disagree with the decision not to prune the tree further or remove it. But it is not fault for a council to properly make a decision with which someone disagrees.
- The outcome Mr X seeks is for the Council to reduce the tree’s height or cut it down. We cannot order councils to use their resources to do work on specific trees, even if they have been the subject of a complaint. That we cannot achieve the outcome Mr X wants is a further reason why we will not investigate.
- We note Mr X says the Council has cut down other trees on his street. Officers may make different decisions on each case brought to them, or at times when the Council’s tree management policy was different. We cannot say any of the removed trees presented the exact situation as the tree outside Mr X’s property. For example, the removed trees may have been diseased. If officers did not follow their policy and approach when they removed other trees, that may be fault. But we would not require the Council to commit further fault to remove another tree which its policy has determined should not be felled.
- Mr X says the tree’s roots have damaged his driveway. If Mr X considers the Council is responsible, this would be a claim of legal liability for private property damage. We cannot decide legal liability claims so will not investigate. Only an insurer or the courts can make those decisions so it is reasonable for Mr X to pursue this route. Mr X may wish to make his claim to the Council’s insurer first and, if the claim is declined, then to the courts.
- We understand Mr X is concerned about branches falling and damaging his car or hurting his family. He says some branches have fallen but have not yet caused damage. If Mr X believes the tree has damaged his car, this would be another claim of legal liability for private property damage. Any injury to him or his family would be a personal injury claim. As with the tree roots and driveway, Mr X may wish to make any such claim to the Council’s insurer first and, if the claim is rejected, to the courts. It would be reasonable for him to do this as only insurers or the courts could make the legal liability for damage or injury decision he would be seeking.
Final decision
- We will not investigate Mr X’s complaint because:
- there is not enough evidence of fault in the Council’s decision-making to warrant us investigating; and
- we cannot achieve the outcome he wants; and
- it would be reasonable for him to pursue any property damage or personal injury claims with the Council’s insurers and at court, if required.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman