Middlesbrough Borough Council (25 020 341)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: The Council was not at fault for giving Ms X the maximum penalty for fly-tipping. The Council is entitled to decide the amount of its fixed penalty notices.
The complaint
- Ms X complained the Council issued her the maximum fixed penalty notice for fly-tipping without justification and without considering her circumstances. She said the Council acted disproportionately, unfairly, and it failed to follow guidance.
- Ms X said it caused stress, worry, frustration and financial pressure. She felt she had no choice but to pay the penalty notice rather than go to court, because of the impact that might have on her employment.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and s34H(1), as amended)
How I considered this complaint
- I considered the information and documents provided by Ms X and the Council. I spoke to Ms X about the complaint. I considered the relevant legislation and statutory guidance, set out below.
- Ms X and the Council had an opportunity to comment on an earlier draft of this statement. I considered all comments and further information received before I reached a final decision.
What I found
What should have happened
- People have a duty of care when it comes to their domestic waste. Government guidance says people must take all reasonable steps to make sure not to transfer domestic waste to an unauthorised person. There are ways to check if someone is authorised to take domestic waste, including checking the person’s operator’s registration, permit or exemption number.
- It is a criminal offence if someone does not take all reasonable measures to meet their duty of care. Councils can deal with breaches of duty of care through fixed penalty notices or prosecution. While there is no obligation to pay a fixed penalty notice, if someone chooses to pay they will not be prosecuted for the offence.
- If someone chooses not to pay a fixed penalty notice, the council will decide whether to prosecute the offence. The person can then raise a defence in court.
- The government issued guidance for councils on fixed penalty notices for household waste duty of care. This guidance says the range for penalties, as set out in legislation, is from £150 to £600.
What happened
- Ms X paid strangers to remove some of her domestic waste. Her waste was then fly-tipped. The Council investigated and identified the waste as Ms X’s. The Council issued Ms X a fixed penalty notice of £600.
- Ms X challenged the fixed penalty notice. The Council reviewed it and was satisfied it had followed the law. It said Ms X did not check if the strangers were authorised to take her waste. It said Ms X could go to court and argue why she thought she had not committed an offence.
Analysis
- Ms X complained the Council issued the maximum fixed penalty notice for fly-tipping without justification and without considering her circumstances. She said the Council acted disproportionately, unfairly, and it failed to follow guidance.
- As I have set out above, the maximum penalty for these offences is £600. The Council is entitled to decide the amount of its fixed penalty notices. It is not for the Ombudsman to say otherwise. For this reason, the Council was not at fault for issuing Ms X a fixed penalty notice for the maximum amount allowed by law.
Decision
- I find no fault.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman