Sheffield City Council (25 019 546)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: The Council was at fault for delay issuing Mrs X’s child’s Education, Health and Care plan, for poor communication, and for delays handling Mrs X’s complaint. This caused Mrs X uncertainty and cost her time and trouble. The Council will make a payment to remedy the injustice. We have not upheld the rest of the complaint.
The complaint
- Mrs X complained about the way the Council handled her child B’s Education, Health and Care (EHC) plan. Specifically, Mrs X complained:
- the Council delayed issuing B’s EHC plan;
- the Council communicated poorly about the EHC plan;
- the Council failed to advise her to apply for help with school transport when she said she was struggling;
- about the content of a draft EHC plan; and,
- the Council delayed dealing with her complaint.
- Mrs X said this caused unnecessary stress. She said it meant she had to deal with the administration of B’s EHC plan during the school holidays. Mrs X said she is out of pocket because she did multiple trips to school to facilitate B’s part-time timetable when the Council did not advise her to apply for help with school transport.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may suggest a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
- The Ombudsman’s view, based on caselaw, is that ‘service failure’ is an objective, factual question about what happened. A finding of service failure does not imply blame, intent or bad faith on the part of the council involved. There may be circumstances where we conclude service failure has occurred and caused an injustice to the complainant despite the best efforts of the council. This still amounts to fault. We may recommend a remedy for the injustice caused and/or that the council makes service improvements. (R (on the application of ER) v CLA (LGO) [2014] EWCA civ 1407)
- The Local Government Act 1974 sets out our powers but also imposes restrictions on what we can investigate.
- The law says we cannot normally investigate a complaint when someone has a right of appeal, reference or review to a tribunal about the same matter. However, we may decide to investigate if we consider it would be unreasonable to expect the person to use this right. (Local Government Act 1974, section 26(6)(a), as amended)
- The First-tier Tribunal (Special Educational Needs and Disability) considers appeals against council decisions regarding special educational needs. We refer to it as the Tribunal in this decision statement.
- Under our information sharing agreement, we will share this decision with the Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills (Ofsted).
- If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
What I have and have not investigated
- Part d of Mrs X’s complaint is about the content of her child’s draft Education, Health and Care (EHC) plan.
- Councils include information they deem necessary and appropriate in draft EHC plans. Parents get an opportunity to comment on draft EHC plans before the council issues the final plan. Once a council has issued the final plan, a parent has the right to appeal the content of the plan at the Tribunal.
- In this case, Mrs X complained about the content of the draft EHC plan. She said the poor quality of the draft plan caused delays issuing the final plan.
- I have not investigated this part of the complaint. This is because draft EHC plans are part of the process of drawing up and issuing final EHC plans. Once an EHC plan is finalised, a parent can appeal the content of the plan to the Tribunal. This means we cannot investigate the content of EHC plans.
- Further to this, the injustice Mrs X said was caused by the poor content of the draft plan was delay issuing the plan. I have investigated this in part a of the complaint.
- For these reasons, I have not investigated part d of the complaint.
- I have investigated parts a, b, c, and e of Mrs X’s complaint.
How I considered this complaint
- I considered the information and documents provided by Mrs X and the Council. I spoke to Mrs X about her complaint. Mrs X and the Council had an opportunity to comment on an earlier draft of this statement. I considered all comments and further information received before I reached a final decision.
- I considered the relevant legislation and statutory guidance, set out below. I also considered the Ombudsman’s published guidance on remedies.
What I found
What should have happened
Education, Health and Care plans
- A child or young person with special educational needs may have an Education, Health and Care (EHC) plan. This plan sets out the child’s needs and what arrangements should be made to meet them. The EHC plan is set out in sections. We cannot direct changes to the sections about their needs, education, or the name of the educational placement. Only the Tribunal or the council can do this.
- Statutory guidance ‘Special educational needs and disability code of practice: 0 to 25 years’ (‘the Code’) sets out the process for carrying out EHC assessments and producing EHC plans. The guidance is based on the Children and Families Act 2014 and the SEN Regulations 2014. It says the following:
- Where the council receives a request for an EHC needs assessment it must decide whether to agree to the assessment and send its decision to the parent of the child or the young person within six weeks.
- The process of assessing needs and developing EHC plans “must be carried out in a timely manner”. Steps must be completed as soon as practicable.
- If the council decides to issue an EHC plan, the whole process from the point when an assessment is requested until the final EHC plan is issued must take no more than 20 weeks (unless certain specific circumstances apply).
Complaint handling
- The Council’s complaint handling policy sets out timeframes for responding to complaints. There is a two-stage procedure.
- The policy says the Council will acknowledge a complaint within five working days. It says it will then respond to the complaint at the first stage (stage one) within ten working days of acknowledging the complaint.
- If a complainant asks for the second stage (stage two), the policy says the Council will acknowledge that request within five working days. The policy says the Council will then respond at stage two within 20 working days of acknowledging the complaint.
What happened
- In February 2025, Mrs X asked the Council for an Education, Health and Care (EHC) needs assessment for her child, B.
- In July, Mrs X complained.
- In September, the Council issued B’s EHC plan.
- In its complaint responses, the Council apologised for delays issuing B’s EHC plan and for not keeping Mrs X updated. The Council said its special educational needs and disability (SEND) team did not deal with school transport. It said Mrs X had applied for school transport for B, and its travel team could give her more information.
- Mrs X then complained to the Ombudsman.
Analysis
Delay issuing the Education, Health and Care plan
- Mrs X complained the Council delayed issuing her child B’s Education, Health and Care (EHC) plan (part a of the complaint).
- The Council had 20 weeks from the date Mrs X asked for an EHC needs assessment to issue the final EHC plan. The Council should have issued the final EHC plan in July. It actually issued the final EHC plan in September, two months late. This is fault.
- In its complaint response, the Council accepted delays issuing the EHC plan. It apologised. The Council said the main cause of this was delay in the educational psychology service. This is a national issue. For this reason, I find this is service failure.
- As I have said in paragraph four, a finding of service failure does not imply blame, intent or bad faith on the Council’s part. In this case, I find a service failure has occurred and caused an injustice despite the Council’s best efforts.
- I find this service failure caused Mrs X injustice because it caused uncertainty. I am satisfied with the Council’s apology for the injustice caused. However, I consider it appropriate and proportionate to recommend a financial remedy for this injustice (see below).
Communication
- Mrs X complained the Council communicated poorly about the EHC plan (part b of the complaint).
- In its complaint response, the Council accepted it had not kept Mrs X updated about the delay issuing the EHC plan. This is fault. This caused Mrs X injustice because it caused uncertainty.
- The Council apologised for the injustice caused by this. I am satisfied the apology is a proportionate and appropriate remedy for the level of injustice caused, and was in line with our guidance on remedies. For this reason, I have not proposed any further remedy for this injustice.
- Mrs X also complained the Council failed to send certain documents with a draft EHC plan.
- The Council said in its complaint response that it had sent the documents with the draft plan.
- Mrs X told me that, in hindsight, she has seen that the Council did send her the documents she said were missing, with the draft plan. Mrs X does not remember why she complained about this. She now thinks she must have complained because the Council sent the documents by zip file which she said is not accessible to everyone.
- I have considered Mrs X’s complaint to us. She was clear that her complaint was that the Council failed to send certain documents with the draft. She said this was a common fault with the Council and referred to another complaint she made to the Ombudsman “where they omitted the same” for her other child.
- I find that Mrs X’s complaint was that the Council failed to send the documents. Mrs X’s complaint was not that she had difficulty accessing the documents.
- I find the Council did send the documents to Mrs X with the draft EHC plan. I therefore do not find the Council at fault.
School transport advice
- Mrs X complained the Council failed to advise her to apply for help with school transport when she said she was struggling (part c of the complaint). Mrs X said she was struggling because she had one child with high-level needs at home all the time, another that went to school full-time, and B who went to school part-time. Mrs X said this meant multiple trips to and from schools every day, totalling 18 school trips in a week.
- Mrs X said the Council was aware she was struggling because she had told other Council departments. She said the Council’s special educational needs team should have been aware of her struggles because it knew about her other children’s needs and circumstances as well as B’s. Mrs X said therefore when she asked the Council to assess B for an EHC plan, it should have advised her to apply for help with school transport for B.
- Councils do not have a duty to suggest to parents who ask for EHC assessments for their children that they should apply for help with school transport. I therefore do not find the Council at fault for not suggesting to Mrs X that she could apply for this help.
- This Council department did not make the link between Miss X’s other children it dealt with and information other Council departments knew about B and their siblings. And it did not consider whether to advise Mrs X that she could apply for help with school transport in light of this. I do not consider it reasonable to expect the Council to have done this. Therefore, the Council is not at fault for this.
- Mrs X said the Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND) Code of Practice is relevant here. The Code sets out the process for EHC needs assessments and making EHC plans. Mrs X said the relevant paragraph is 9.33, which says:
“As far as possible, there should be a ‘tell us once’ approach to sharing information during the assessment and planning process so that families and young people do not have to repeat the same information to different agencies, or different practitioners and services within each agency.”
- I do not agree that this paragraph is relevant to this part of Mrs X’s complaint. The previous paragraph in the Code gives context to paragraph 9.33. Paragraph 9.32 says:
“Information sharing is vital to support an effective assessment and planning process which fully identifies needs and outcomes and the education, health and care provision needed by the child or young person.”
- Paragraph 9.32 is clear that the information gathering referred to in paragraph 9.33 is information about the child, in order to assess the child’s needs and outcomes. I find the paragraph 9.33 says families should not have to give information about their child more than once.
- I do not consider paragraph 9.33 of the Code is relevant to whether the Council should have suggested to Mrs X that she could apply for school transport help, simply because she asked the Council for an EHC assessment for B and other Council departments may have known about Mrs X’s struggles.
Complaint handling
- Mrs X complained the Council delayed dealing with her complaint (part e of the complaint).
- I agree. The Council failed to acknowledge Mrs X’s complaint. It then delayed sending its stage one complaint response by three months. This is fault. I find this fault cost Mrs X time and trouble, which is injustice.
- In its stage one complaint response, the Council accepted it failed to acknowledge Mrs X’s complaint, and it delayed responding to her complaint. It apologised for this. I am satisfied with the Council’s apology.
- However, I do not consider the apology alone is an appropriate and proportionate remedy for the level of injustice here. I have addressed this below.
- I find the Council sent its stage two response one day late. This is not significant enough to be fault.
- The Council said it has taken action to resolve issues with its complaint handling. It said it has employed more staff, created new roles including a senior inclusion officer dedicated to complaints, and provided clearer ownership of complaints. The Council said it has also identified learning from this complaint. This is positive. Because of this, I am satisfied there is no need to recommend further service improvements.
Action
- Within four weeks of this decision, the Council has agreed to make a payment of £300 to Mrs X.
- I have arrived at this figure in the following way:
- For part a of the complaint: our published guidance on remedies sets out a usual payment of £100 per month of delay issuing a final Education, Health and Care plan as a result of service failure because of an educational psychology service. In this case, there was two months of delay. Two months multiplied by £100 per month is £200.
- For part e of the complaint: I have taken into account the length of the delay sending the stage one complaint response (three months) and the significance of the level of injustice. I consider a payment of £100 is appropriate and proportionate to remedy this injustice.
- £200 plus £100 is £300.
- The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above action.
Decision
- I find fault causing injustice. The Council has agreed to take action to remedy injustice.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman