North Yorkshire Council (24 022 862)

Category : Education > Special educational needs

Decision : Upheld

Decision date : 05 Oct 2026

The Ombudsman's final decision:

Summary: The Council has already found fault in the way it managed and finalised the complainant’s child’s (Z’s) Education, Health and Care (EHC) Plan, recognising that this delayed the complainant’s right of appeal. We find fault in that the Council failed to provide appropriate oversight of the alternative education which Z was receiving. The Council has agreed the recommended ways to remedy the injustice caused. We have therefore completed our investigation and are closing the complaint.

The complaint

  1. Mrs X complained that the Council:
      1. delayed between July 2023 and September 2024 in issuing a final Education, Health and Care (EHC) Plan for Mrs X’s daughter, Z;
      2. refused to agree to a personal budget without good reason;
      3. failed to provide alternative education under section 19 when it became aware that Z was unable to attend their school due to extreme anxiety;
      4. delayed, after the November 2025 Tribunal decision, in ensuring the special educational needs (SEN) provision set out in Z’s final EHC Plans was delivered; and
      5. delayed in investigating Mrs X’s complaints.
  2. Mrs X says that the Council’s faults have meant that Z has missed out on educational provision at a key stage in her school career, and she and the family have been caused avoidable time and trouble, distress and frustration.

Back to top

The Ombudsman’s role and powers

  1. We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’.
  2. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may suggest a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
  3. We cannot investigate late complaints unless we decide there are good reasons. Late complaints are when someone takes more than 12 months to complain to us about something a council has done. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26B and 34D, as amended)
  4. The First-tier Tribunal (Special Educational Needs and Disability-SEND) considers appeals against council decisions regarding special educational needs. We refer to it as the SEND Tribunal in this decision statement.
  5. We will not normally investigate a complaint whereby the complainant had an alternative remedy by means of appeal to the SEND Tribunal unless we consider that there are reasons why the complainant could not resort to this remedy.
  6. The courts have established that, if someone has appealed to the Tribunal, the law says we cannot investigate any matter which was part of, was connected to, or could have been part of, the appeal to the Tribunal. (R (on application of Milburn) v Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman [2023] EWCA Civ 207).
  7. But, if there are issues separate from the substance, consequences or conduct of an appeal, we may be able to investigate.
  8. If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended).
  9. Under our information sharing agreement, we will share this decision with the Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills (Ofsted).

Back to top

What I have and have not investigated

  1. Mrs X complained to the Ombudsman in March 2025. We referred the complaint back to the Council for it to investigate.
  2. I decided to exercise discretion to look at the complaints from July 2023, when the Council agreed to carry out an EHC needs assessment, even though the complainant did not complain to us within the required 12 months. I have exercised discretion because of Mrs X’s personal circumstances.
  3. Mrs X had a right of appeal to the SEND Tribunal in September 2024 when the Council issued Z’s final EHC Plan. The law says we cannot normally investigate a complaint when someone has a right of appeal, reference, or review to a tribunal about the same matter. As Mrs X used her right to appeal to challenge what the EHC plan said about Z’s special educational needs in section B, the provision set out in section F, and the school named in section I, we have no discretion to consider investigating any complaint she may have about these issues.
  4. However, if there is medical evidence that a child is too unwell to attend any school, that is not connected to the SEND appeal, we can investigate the educational provision the child received. This is relevant to Mrs X’s complaint about the lack of education for Z for the period of June to November 2025.
  5. I decided that the end point of my investigation should be February 2026 to include Mrs X’s complaint about the Council’s delay in implementing the Tribunal Order of November 2025 because it relates to an ongoing issue.

Back to top

How I considered this complaint

  1. I have spoken to Mrs X on the telephone. I considered evidence provided by the Council and by Mrs X as well as relevant law, policy and guidance, set out below.
  2. The Council investigated the complaints and accepted the delay in issuing the EHC Plan, and other related matters. The Council offered a remedy, which Mrs X declined. Therefore, I looked at the injustice caused by the accepted faults and whether the remedy was appropriate.
  3. But I also considered whether the Council’s investigation covered all the related matters and made appropriate findings about the lack of alternative education.
  4. I issued a draft decision statement to the Council and to Mrs X. I have taken into account their further comments before reaching my final decision.

Back to top

What I found

EHC Plans

  1. A child or young person with special educational needs may have an Education, Health and Care (EHC) Plan. This document sets out the child’s needs and what arrangements should be made to meet them. The EHC Plan is set out in sections. We cannot direct changes to the sections about their needs, education, or the name of the educational placement. Only the Tribunal or the council can do this. 

Timescales and process for EHC assessment 

  1. Statutory guidance ‘Special educational needs and disability code of practice: 0 to 25 years’ (‘the Code’) sets out the process for carrying out EHC assessments and producing EHC Plans. The guidance is based on the Children and Families Act 2014 and the SEN Regulations 2014.
  2. If the council decides to proceed with an EHC Plan, the council should complete this within 20 weeks (subject to certain exemptions) from the date of the EHC needs assessment.

Advice and Information for EHC needs assessments

  1. As part of the assessment, councils must gather advice from relevant professionals (SEND Regulation 6(1)). This includes: 
  • psychological advice and information from an Educational Psychologist (EP); 
  1. Those consulted have a maximum of six weeks to provide the advice. 

Alternative provision

  1. The Education Act 1996 places a duty on parents to ensure their children of compulsory school age receive a suitable full-time education. Failure to meet this duty is an offence.  
  2. Councils must arrange suitable education at school or elsewhere for pupils who are out of school because of exclusion, illness or for other reasons, if they would not receive suitable education without such arrangements. We refer to this as section 19 or alternative education provision.
  3. The Children, Schools and Families Act 2010 clarified that a suitable education means fulltime education. The only exception is where the physical and/or mental health of the child means fulltime education would not be in the child’s best interests.
  4. The courts have considered the circumstances where the section 19 duty applies. Caselaw has established that a council will have a duty to provide alternative education under section 19 if there is no suitable education available to the child which is “reasonably practicable” for the child to access. The “acid test” is whether educational provision the council has offered is “available and accessible to the child”. (R (on the application of DS) v Wolverhampton City Council 2017)
  5. Schools should notify the council of any cases where a child is accessing reduced/part-time education arrangements.
  6. Councils should consider any attempts the school is making to support the child. This might involve sending work home for the child to complete, arranging disability related support, placing the child on a reduced timetable, or providing online education as a short-term measure. If there is a clear, effective, and time-bound plan for reintegration then there may be no immediate role for the council in providing alternative education.

The Ombudsman’s guidance

  1. We publish good practice guidance on how we expect councils to fulfil their responsibilities to identify and arrange alternative educational provision: ‘Supporting children out of school’. (October 2025) Our guidance says, relevant to this case, that councils should:
  • consider all the reasons for a child’s absence from school and make a written evidence-based decision about whether it will arrange alternative education provision.
  • as a matter of good practice, it should communicate this decision to parents. Where a council decides not to arrange alternative education, it should tell parents the expectations about school attendance, and the potential consequences for continued absences.
  • work with parents and schools to draw up plans to reintegrate children to their normal educational setting as soon as possible, reviewing and amending plans as necessary.
  • ensure effective channels of communication between parents, internal teams, and external bodies (such as schools, and the NHS) to ensure issues are dealt with promptly by the right people, and any complaints are identified and responded to under the relevant policy.
  1. Where councils arrange for schools or other bodies to carry out their functions on their behalf, the council remains responsible. Councils should keep oversight and control to ensure their duties are properly fulfilled.

The Council’s alternative education procedures

  1. The Council says that, when a child does not have an EHC Plan, and is on roll at a school, in the first instance it is the responsibility of the school to engage with the family to establish the reasons for the non-attendance and whether it is appropriate for work to be sent home or otherwise.
  2. The Council says that it is for the allocated school to arrange alternative education if a pupil is not attending.

Where a pupil is too unwell to attend school, the school can make a referral to the Council’s Medical Education Team (MET). The MET is its provider of alternative education under section 19.

Key facts

  1. Z stopped attending her secondary school in February 2022 due to severe anxiety.
  2. In May 2023, the Council received a referral to its Medical Education Team (MET) from Z’s school, School B. The Council’s MET Panel considered the referral from Z’s school.
  3. The MET began working with Z in May 2023 when the family moved into its area and Z was on roll at School B. But the Council has not provided any further information about what this involvement entailed for this initial period.
  4. Mrs X says that School B provided very little tuition when Z could not attend. Mrs X did not complain to the Governing Body of School B about this limited education because, in July 2023, School B helped her to apply for and obtain an EHC needs assessment.
  5. In August 2023, the Council agreed to carry out an EHC needs assessment on Z and it sent out requests for professional advice. Professionals had six weeks to provide this. The Council sent out reminders regularly.

Events of 2024

  1. In January 2024, the Council wrote to Mrs X explaining that there was a national shortage of Educational Psychologists (EPs).
  2. The EP sent professional advice in mid-March 2024 and, in June, the Council’s Panel decided to proceed with an EHC Plan. In August 2024, the Council issued a draft EHC Plan.
  3. Mrs X wanted to have a meeting with the Council’s caseworker (as was her right) to discuss the draft EHC Plan because she wanted to explore the possibility of an Education Otherwise Than At School (EOTAS) package and a personal budget. The Council failed to arrange this. Mrs X explained that she wanted to arrange alternative educational provision from Provider C and Provider D.
  4. In September 2024, the Council wrote to Mrs X, refusing a personal budget because School B should commission the provision from Provider C and that Provider D was not on the Council’s approved provider list for alternative education.
  5. In mid-September 2024, the Council issued a final EHC Plan, naming School B, although Mrs X had said the EP had recommended EOTAS. Mrs X’s right to appeal to the SEND Tribunal was triggered. Mrs X attempted to reach an agreement with the Council. She was still seeking an EOTAS package. In the absence of an agreement, Mrs X pursued her appeal to the SEND Tribunal.
  6. In December 2024, Mrs X complained to the Council about the lack of appropriate education for Z, the delay in issuing a final EHC Plan and failure to hold a meeting to discuss the draft EHC Plan.

Events of 2025

  1. Between December 2024 to March 2025, Provider C started to offer forty-five minutes of support four days per week. But Z struggled to engage.
  2. In May, the Council replied to Mrs X at stage one of its corporate complaints’ procedure (six months after Mrs X’s complaint). It apologised for the delay in replying. The Council’s procedures say stage one complaints should be responded to within fifteen working days but can be extended to twenty days.
  3. The Council upheld the complaint about the delay in issuing a final EHC Plan, the failure to hold a meeting at the draft EHC Plan stage and a delay in holding a mediation meeting (this is not part of this investigation).
  4. The Council did not uphold any complaint about the educational provision while Z was not attending school.
  5. In May 2025, the Council’s MET Panel considered Z’s non-attendance. It agreed that Z should be offered home tuition together with her sibling. The Council says that initially it offered one hour per week tuition of English and one hour of Mathematics.
  6. Mrs X paid for Z to have animal therapy and psychology support. She says that she paid about £2,500 for educational provision, as well as this for Z’s sibling.
  7. The Council sent its stage two complaint response at the end of July 2025. It confirmed the findings made at stage one, emphasising that School B, once Z’s EHC Plan was issued, could have asked the Council to increase the funding if it did not consider it could provide appropriate alternative provision.
  8. The Council offered £100 for each month of delay caused by the delay in receiving the EP report and £100 for the avoidable distress, making a total of £1,000, which Mrs X has not accepted.
  9. In November 2025, the Tribunal ordered an EOTIC (Education Otherwise Than In College) because by this stage Z was past the statutory school age. The package consisted of twenty-five hours tuition. Mrs X says that it was not until February 2026 that the Council started to provide this package.
  10. Mrs X says that she has noticed a significant improvement in Z’s educational achievement and well-being since starting this package.
  11. The Council says it started looking for providers in mid-December 2025 with a start date of early January 2026. But because of the Christmas break, the Council accepts that there was a short delay in making the provision. However, the Council says a tutor was available from early February 2026, but Mrs X refused the tutor because he was male. Mrs X denies this.

The Council’s SEN improvement plan

  1. The Council has had a SEN strategy plan (2023 to 2026) to strengthen the availability of EPs. It is also transforming its EHC Plan process by introducing a digital system.
  2. In addition, the Council has a School Improvement Team. Its advisers hold regular meetings with schools regarding attendance. Schools with a poor attendance record, its advisers meet termly. For other schools, meetings are yearly.

Back to top

Findings

Complaint (a): delayed in issuing a final EHC Plan

  1. The Council has accepted it took nine months to finalise the EHC Plan for Z which was issued in September 2024. The Council recognised that this frustrated Mrs X’s right of appeal to the SEND Tribunal. The Council has offered a symbolic payment of £100 for each month of delay and £100 for the avoidable distress (based on our guidance where delays are caused by the national shortage of EPs).

Complaint (b): refused a personal budget without good reason

  1. The Council refused a personal budget because it was for School B to commission the alternative provision, and School B provided this from Provider C for the period of December 2024 to March 2025.
  2. The Council also refused a personal budget when it issued Z’s final EHC Plan. The SEND Tribunal could not determine this issue. However, it was agreed that the Council would commission and manage the funding for Z’s educational package.
  3. The Ombudsman cannot question councils’ decisions, properly made, however much a complainant disagrees with them. My view is that the Council provided a reason for not agreeing the personal budget when requested. I am also mindful that the Council is managing the budget for Z’s current educational package.
  4. However, the Council failed to arrange a meeting as requested by Mrs X at the draft EHC Plan stage. The Council has accepted this was fault. This would have been an appropriate time to discuss directly with Mrs X her request for a personal budget.
  5. So, I consider this fault resulted in a lost opportunity to have information explained directly to Mrs X.

Complaint (c): failed to provide alternative education

  1. The Council relied upon School B to provide alternative education for Z from July 2023 to September 2024. And it says it provided funding for it to do so.
  2. Despite asking the Council to provide specific details of the education provided to Z from July 2023 (when it became aware of her non-attendance), it has not done so. December 2024 is the first reference the Council has made to the alternative education provided by School B. So, I cannot be satisfied the Council had an appropriate oversight of what alternative provision School B was providing.
  3. Moreover, the Council said that its agreement to undertake an EHC needs assessment was also a way to assess the suitability of School B for Z. But I cannot see evidence that, during the time it took to assess Z’s needs, there was a corresponding assessment, showing how the Council satisfied itself Z was receiving a suitable education during this period, or how it considered whether School B was making appropriate plans for Z’s reintegration, an important consideration given the Council maintained School B was suitable and available.
  4. My view is that these failures amount to fault, causing avoidable distress to Mrs X and a loss of education for Z for the period of July 2023 (the start date of my investigation) to September 2024.
  5. After September 2024, when the Council issued Z’s final EHC Plan, Mrs X’s appeal rights were triggered. As stated, we cannot consider complaints about educational provision if we consider they are closely connected to matters a Tribunal will or has considered. However, where a pupil is too unwell to attend any school, we can investigate the lack of educational provision as this is not related to the appeal.
  6. I consider that, in May 2025, the Council decided Z was too unwell to attend any school and its MET offered home tuition for two hours per week. But I cannot find evidence to support the Council’s decision on why two hours per week was suitable, especially in the context that Z was in her GCSE year.
  7. I am also mindful that Z has been managing twenty-five hours per week since February 2026. This may be partly to make up for previous lost education. But it does support Mrs X’s argument that Z wanted to be in education and potentially could have managed more than the two hours offered back in May 2025.

Complaint (d): failed to make the EOTIC provision after the Tribunal decision of November 2025

  1. The Council had five weeks after the Tribunal decision to implement the ordered educational package. The Council sought providers in mid-December with a start date of early January 2026. The Council accepts that there was a delay in the package starting. However, there was an available tutor from the beginning of February 2026 which Mrs X refused because the tutor was male.
  2. I find that there was a slight delay in starting the EOTIC package for Z, and that is fault.

Complaint (e): delay in considering Mrs X’s complaints

  1. The Council has accepted that there was a delay in dealing with Mrs X’s complaints, particularly at stage one. It has apologised. This delay has caused Mrs X avoidable time and trouble and frustration.

Back to top

Action

  1. I considered our guidance on remedies. I also considered Z’s special educational needs, the lack of provision, and the impact this had on the family as a whole.
  2. The Council has already offered a remedy for the earlier delay and avoidable distress in issuing the EHC Plan. I consider that this remedy (£900) is appropriate for the injustice caused by the EP delay and the delay in issuing a final EHC Plan.
  3. We cannot look at the lack of educational provision once Mrs X’s appeal rights were triggered in September 2024. However, by late May 2025, the Council decided that Z was too ill to attend school. The reasons for Z not attending school were distinct from the issues under appeal. So, we can look at remedying the loss of education between June to November 2025 (approximately four school months) in accordance with our guidance on the loss of education.
  4. That guidance recommends between £900 to £2,400 per term of lost education. I am aware that Mrs X has incurred costs providing some provision for Z when not at school. But I consider the recommendation below provides an appropriate remedy.
  5. Within one month of the final statement, the Council will:
      1. apologise to Mrs X for the faults and injustice which I have identified. We publish guidance on remedies which sets out our expectations for how organisations should apologise effectively to remedy injustice. The organisation should consider this guidance in making the apology I have recommended in my findings;
      2. make the symbolic payment of £900 to Mrs X which the Council has already offered for the delays in completing Z’s EHC Plan, and pay the £100 for the delay in dealing with the complaint;
      3. there was a lack of proper oversight of the alternative education provided by School B between July 2023 to September 2024 (when Mrs X’s appeal rights were triggered). The Council will make a symbolic payment of £500 for this period; and
      4. there was a loss of alternative education between June to November 2025 when Z was too ill to attend any school. I recognize that the Council provided some tuition, although there is insufficient evidence to explain why only two hours per week was considered appropriate. The Council will make a symbolic payment to Mrs X of £2,400 for this.
  6. I am not recommending any service improvements because we have recommended these before in other complaints and the Council has an action plan to try to prevent similar faults occurring.
  7. The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above actions.

Back to top

Decision

  1. I find fault causing injustice. The Council has agreed the remedies. I have therefore completed my investigation and am closing the complaint.

Back to top

Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman

Print this page

LGO logogram

Review your privacy settings

Required cookies

These cookies enable the website to function properly. You can only disable these by changing your browser preferences, but this will affect how the website performs.

View required cookies

Analytical cookies

Google Analytics cookies help us improve the performance of the website by understanding how visitors use the site.
We recommend you set these 'ON'.

View analytical cookies

In using Google Analytics, we do not collect or store personal information that could identify you (for example your name or address). We do not allow Google to use or share our analytics data. Google has developed a tool to help you opt out of Google Analytics cookies.

Privacy settings