Surrey County Council (25 013 884)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: Ms X complains the Council did not provide suitable education for her son after he was excluded from school. It placed him in an unsuitable placement, despite the school and the headteacher at the placement agreeing it was not suitable. We uphold the complaint. There was no fault in the Council’s decision to make the referral to the placement, as this followed its own policy. But it did not keep the child’s progress at the placement under review, despite the duty to provide the alternative education resting with it. We have made recommendations for personal remedies and a service improvement.
The complaint
- The complainant (Ms X) complains the Council:
- failed to provide suitable educational provision to her son (B) after he was excluded from school;
- ignored the opinions of staff at B’s primary school and at the Pupil Referral Unit placement that the placement was not suitable.
- Ms X says B did not have consistently effective education at the placement. And his mental health deteriorated when he did not have a suitable school place.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
- The law says we cannot normally investigate a complaint when someone has a right of appeal, reference or review to a tribunal about the same matter. However, we may decide to investigate if we consider it would be unreasonable to expect the person to use this right. (Local Government Act 1974, section 26(6)(a), as amended)
- The First-tier Tribunal (Special Educational Needs and Disability) considers appeals against council decisions regarding special educational needs. We refer to it as the Tribunal in this decision statement.
- If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
- Under our information sharing agreement, we will share this decision with the Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills (Ofsted).
What I have and have not investigated
- For the reasons set out in paragraphs 4 and 5, the contents of B’s Educational, Health and Care (EHC) Plan are outside the Ombudsman’s jurisdiction, as Ms X has appealed the Council’s decision on its EHC needs assessments.
- The courts have established that if someone has appealed to the Tribunal, the law says we cannot investigate any matter which was part of, was connected to, or could have been part of, the appeal to the Tribunal. (R (on application of Milburn) v Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman [2023] EWCA Civ 207)
- The period we cannot investigate starts from the date the appealable decision is made and given to the parents or young person. If the parent or young person goes on to appeal then the period that we cannot investigate ends when the Tribunal comes to its decision, or if the appeal is withdrawn or conceded. We would not usually look at the period while any changes to the EHC Plan are finalised, so long as the council follows the statutory timescales to make those amendments.
- We can look at matters that do not have a right of appeal, are not connected to an appeal, or are not a consequence of an appeal. For example alternative education when the reason the child or young person is not attending education is, in our view, not connected to or is not a consequence of a matter that was, or could have been, part of an appeal to the Tribunal. As the Council’s duties to provide alternative education for B were due to his exclusion, this is a matter we can investigate.
- My investigation ends in September 2025, at the time of Ms X’s complaint to the Ombudsman.
How I considered this complaint
- I considered evidence provided by Ms X and the Council as well as relevant law, policy and guidance.
- Ms X and the Council had an opportunity to comment on my draft decision. I considered any comments before making a final decision.
What I found
Legal and administrative background
Alternative provision
- Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 says that a council must arrange suitable alternative educational provision when it finds that a child is unable to attend school because of a permanent exclusion, an illness, or for any other reason which make the school inaccessible to the child. The alternative educational provision must be suitable for the child’s age, ability and aptitude, and any special educational needs they have.
- In cases where a child is permanently excluded from a school, the law says that provision must be arranged for the child from the sixth day after the exclusion. This is set out in The Education (Provision of Full-Time Education for Excluded Pupils) (England) Regulations 2007 (SI 2007/1870) and accompanying statutory guidance)
- The Council has a policy statement on how it discharges its duties under Section 19 of the Education Act. This sets out its statutory duties and associated guidance. It says, for children subject to exclusion from school, it discharges its duties through referral to the County’s Pupil Referral Units.
Guide for practitioners
- We publish good practice guidance on how we expect councils to fulfil their responsibilities to identify and arrange alternative educational provision: Supporting children out of school (October 2025)
- Our guidance says that, where councils arrange for schools or other bodies to carry out their functions on their behalf, the council remains responsible. Therefore councils should retain oversight and control to ensure their duties are properly fulfilled.
What happened
- This section sets out the key events in this case and is not meant to be a detailed chronology.
- B has a diagnosis of an autism spectrum condition, with additional challenges around social communication, emotional regulation and anxiety management.
- Ms X applied for an EHC Plan for B in the spring of 2024. After an assessment, the Council decided not to issue a Plan. In October 2024 Ms X appealed that decision.
- In January 2025 B was permanently excluded from his primary school. The school notified the Council.
- The Council was in contact with the school. The school agreed to provide some alternative provision for the first weeks after B’s exclusion – until the February half-term.
- The Council referred B to a Pupil Referral Unit (Organisation 1). Ms X declined the placement initially. She says she spoke to Organisation 1’s headteacher who said they would push back on the Council’s view that it was an appropriate placement for B. But then the headteacher said the Council disagreed and said it had to accept B into the school.
- The Council’s records show it was in touch with Organisation 1, which advised:
- it had spoken to Ms X who had refused the placement, as she did not feel it was an appropriate setting;
- Ms X refused its suggestion she visit it before doing so. She advised she would continue with the provision put in place by the school;
- Ms X told it she would send a letter from a psychiatrist showing B was not able to attend on medical grounds. The Council advised Organisation 1 to put B on its role until it received medical evidence, after which it could look at alternatives.
- The records the Council sent me do not cover the next period. Ms X advises she did then agree for B to attend Organisation 1, as the Council would not change its decision.
- But B then did not start at Organisation 1 until mid-March. Ms X says this was partly due to their attempts to secure different provision. There were also some issues with arranging transport. Ms X has told me that after starting B’s attendance was inconsistent, due to some issues over clothing and the security set up at the building.
- In April, after intervention from the Tribunal, the Council agreed to issue an EHC Plan. In June Ms X appealed the final Plan as it specified mainstream provision. In mid-June, the Council agreed to change the placement type in the EHC Plan from mainstream to specialist provision. It began a consultation process.
- Ms X complained. As part of the Council’s complaint investigation, an inclusion officer contacted Organisation 1’s headteacher. They advised of B’s sporadic attendance since Easter. They noted the measures and adjustments Organisation 1 had made in response.
- The Council’s complaint response said the provision, first from the primary school and later by Organisation 1, show it had sufficient evidence to suggest that it had not failed in its Section 19 duties.
- Towards the end of September, after the start of the school year, one of the schools the Council had consulted confirmed it had a placement. B started at a specialist setting in November.
- Ms B complained to the Ombudsman in September 2025. In response to my enquires, the Council advised it had an Action Plan to seek improvement on how it could improve its discharge of its duties, under Section 19 of the Education Act, to provide alternative education.
Analysis and findings
- There was no fault in the way the Council initially discharged its duties under Section 19 of the Education Act, as it made alternative education available to B, via the route set out in its policy statement.
- Ms X’s view was the placement was unsuitable. She says the school and Organisation 1 agreed with that view. But a review of the Council’s file does not show either the school or Organisation 1 relaying this view to the Council. The Council correctly told Organisation 1 it could review suitability on receipt of medical evidence. B did not then have an EHC Plan. And when the Council did issue an EHC Plan, it specified mainstream provision. I know Ms X challenged those decisions, but that does not allow the Ombudsman to go back and retrospectively say the Council’s decisions on alternative provision were wrong at the time it made them. So I do not uphold the complaint about the Council’s decision to place B at Organisation 1.
- But, as the responsibility to provide the alternative education remained with the Council, I would have expected to see some record of the Council keeping B’s placement under review. It placed him at Organisation 1 in February (although he did not start attending until March). But its records suggest no contact until July – and then only in response to Ms X’s complaint.
- And its decision in June to agree to B’s EHC Plan specifying he needed a specialist placement should also have alerted the Council to review his placement. Its record of its contact in July does not show it took this change into account in its discussions with Organisation 1. To have not done so was fault.
- There is a gap in the Council’s records (see paragraph 27) which was fault.
- For the period before the changes to the EHC Plan we cannot now retrospectively say the Council should have concluded the placement was unsuitable. But if it had kept oversight of the placement, it would have been aware earlier of B’s challenges, leading to the possibility it could have intervened. Although we cannot now know (even on the balance of probabilities) whether intervention would have changed the outcomes for B, that uncertainty is an injustice that demands recognition by way of a symbolic remedy payment.
- The decision to change B’s EHC Plan’s placement type was too near the end of the term to have likely made a meaningful impact on his provision.
Agreed action
- I recommended that, within one month of my final decision the Council take the following actions.
- Apologise. We publish guidance on remedies which sets out our expectations for how organisations should apologise effectively to remedy injustice. The organisation should consider this guidance in making the apology I have recommended in my findings;
- Make Ms X a symbolic payment of £500 for the uncertainty of whether, but for the fault, the outcomes for B from the alternative provision might have been different.
- I recommended that, within three months of my decision, the Council include measures in its Action Plan to ensure it keeps ownership and control of alternative provision, including regular monitoring/communication with service providers as to a child’s progress.
- The Council has agreed to my recommendations.
Decision
- I find fault causing injustice. The Council has agreed actions to remedy injustice.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman