South Holland District Council (25 020 290)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: Mr X complained the Council wrongly revised his Council Tax Support and mishandled the resulting arrears, recovery action, correspondence and complaints. The Council was at fault in its communication, correspondence handling and complaint handling. This caused Mr X avoidable confusion, uncertainty and frustration. The Council has already taken some action to address the injustice caused. It agreed to pay Mr X £100 to recognise the remaining distress and uncertainty.
The complaint
- Mr X complained the Council wrongly retrospectively revised his Council Tax Support, creating Council Tax arrears for previous financial years. He also complained the Council failed to properly explain its decisions, mishandled his correspondence, repeatedly started and stopped recovery action and delayed dealing with his complaints.
- Mr X says this caused him distress, confusion and significant time and trouble pursuing the matter. He wants the Council to acknowledge it acted wrongly and resolve the disputed Council Tax liability.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
- The Valuation Tribunal deals with appeals against decisions on council tax liability and council tax support or reduction.
- The law says we cannot normally investigate a complaint when someone has a right of appeal, reference or review to a tribunal about the same matter. However, we may decide to investigate if we consider it would be unreasonable to expect the person to use this right. (Local Government Act 1974, section 26(6)(a), as amended)
- We cannot investigate a complaint about the start of court action or what happened in court. (Local Government Act 1974, Schedule 5/5A, paragraph 1/3, as amended)
- If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
What I have and have not investigated
- Mr X had a right to challenge the Council's August 2023 Council Tax Support decision and appeal to the Valuation Tribunal. It was reasonable for him to use this right, so this investigation has not considered whether the Council correctly calculated his Council Tax Support.
- The investigation has also not considered the Council's liability order proceedings in the Magistrates' Court, as the Ombudsman cannot investigate matters that have been considered in court.
- The investigation considered the Council's administration, communication, recovery action before court proceedings, and complaint handling.
How I considered this complaint
- I considered evidence provided by Mr X and the Council as well as relevant law, policy and guidance.
- Mr X and the Council had an opportunity to comment on my draft decision. I considered any comments before making a final decision.
What I found
Relevant legislation and guidance
- The tribunal is an independent expert body. The Council must do what the tribunal tells it to. The complainant could appeal to the tribunal in this case.
- There are laws and regulations that control how councils collect council tax payments and how they can make people pay council tax they owe. (Council Tax [Administration and Enforcement] Regulations 1992)
- The council tax bill for the year is due on 1 April. A council will usually collect this through monthly instalments. If a person who has to pay council tax misses any instalment, the council will send them a reminder. If they still do not pay, or miss another payment, then they must pay all they owe (that is the full amount for the rest of the year).
- Councils who want to recover unpaid council tax have to ask the magistrate’s court for a liability order against people it thinks owe it the money. Once a council has a liability order it can take action to recover the money and any court costs owed.
- Most often councils take what is owed directly from the person’s benefits, from their wages (called getting an attachment of earnings order) or using enforcement agents. The council can decide how to recover what is owed but it can only use one method for one liability order at one time.
What happened
- The Council awarded Mr X Council Tax Support based on the income and capital information it held.
- The Council received information through the National Fraud Initiative in June 2023 indicating Mr X may have occupational pension income it did not know about. It checked information held by HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) and identified two occupational pensions.
- The Council wrote to Mr X in mid-June 2023 asking him to confirm when the pensions started, how much he received and to provide supporting financial information.
- Mr X responded and gave approximate start dates for the pensions and provided some bank statements. The Council considered this did not provide sufficient evidence of the pension income throughout the relevant period. It wrote to him again in early July requesting further evidence and gave him one month to respond.
- The Council's records show Mr X subsequently provided further bank statements but did not provide the pension evidence it had requested. The Council decided to apply adverse inference and treated both occupational pensions as having been received from 1 April 2021, when Mr X's claim changed to a pension-age claim.
- The Council revised Mr X's Council Tax Support on 9 August 2023. Its decision explained why it had included the occupational pensions from April 2021. It told Mr X that if the dates or amounts were incorrect, he should provide evidence within one month and it could reconsider his claim. The revision increased the Council Tax payable for previous years.
- The Council also gave Mr X information about how to challenge its decision. The Council says Mr X did not request a reconsideration or appeal the Council Tax Support decision. It has since told him that if he provides the requested pension evidence, it will reconsider his entitlement, and a fresh decision would give him new appeal rights.
- The retrospective revision meant Mr X owed Council Tax for earlier financial years.
- Mr X previously had a direct debit instruction on his Council Tax account. The Council says it had not used the instruction for more than 12 months because there had been no Council Tax to collect. The instruction therefore became dormant. The Council wrote to Mr X in August 2023 asking him to establish a new direct debit.
- Mr X set up a new direct debit in September 2023. The Council used this to collect his current year's Council Tax. It said it also contacted him in September asking him to make a separate arrangement for the earlier-year arrears.
- Mr X continued questioning the arrears and the Council Tax Support decision.
- The Council wrote to Mr X in late November 2023. It explained why the previous direct debit had become dormant and said it had placed the earlier-year arrears on hold for three weeks to allow the Benefits Team to respond to him.
- The Benefits Team contacted Mr X as the Council had indicated it would.
- The Council subsequently accepted it had given Mr X incorrect information. It also accepted it had not properly advised him that he needed to arrange payment of the earlier-year arrears. It placed recovery on hold and agreed to remove reminder and summons costs.
- The Council withdrew recovery action in March 2024 while it checked the account and clarified the position. Mr X continued corresponding with the Council and through his local Member of Parliament (MP).
- The Council reviewed the position again in February 2025. It acknowledged its previous correspondence contributed to Mr X's misunderstanding of the arrears. It apologised, withdrew the recovery action and associated costs and gave Mr X another opportunity to contact it about payment.
- The Council continued telling Mr X it would reconsider the Council Tax Support decision if he provided evidence of when his occupational pensions began and the amounts received.
- Mr X complained to the Council in May 2025. The Council issued its Stage 1 response on 17 July. It partly upheld his complaint and accepted it had failed to respond to some correspondence because of an administrative filing error.
- Mr X escalated his complaint in mid-September 2025. The Council issued its Stage 2 response on 23 October. It did not uphold his allegations against individual officers but accepted there had been administrative errors involving correspondence.
Analysis and findings
Council Tax Support decision
- Councils may revise Council Tax Support where new information affects a person's entitlement. A person who disagrees with a Council Tax Support decision can use the statutory process to challenge the decision and ultimately appeal to the Valuation Tribunal.
- We normally expect someone to use a statutory appeal where it is reasonable for them to do so. We are not an alternative appeal body and do not decide whether a Council Tax Support calculation is correct where that question could reasonably have been considered through the statutory appeal process.
- The evidence shows the Council did not retrospectively revise Mr X's Council Tax Support without making enquiries. It identified previously undeclared pension income, obtained information from HMRC, contacted Mr X twice for evidence, considered the information he supplied and recorded why it considered further evidence was required. The Council recorded why it applied adverse inference when Mr X did not provide sufficient evidence.
- There was no evidence of administrative fault in the process the Council followed before making its decision.
- Mr X disagreed with the Council's decision to treat the pensions as having been received from April 2021 and the resulting Council Tax liability. These matters concern the merits of the Council Tax Support decision. Mr X had a statutory route to challenge the decision but did not use it. The Ombudsman will therefore not decide whether the Council used the correct pension commencement dates or calculated Mr X's Council Tax Support correctly.
- The Council also confirmed it remains willing to reconsider the decision if Mr X supplies the outstanding pension evidence. A new decision would give him fresh appeal rights.
Direct debit and the cause of the arrears
- Mr X says problems with the Council's computer system and the removal of his direct debit caused the arrears.
- The evidence does not support this. Mr X's earlier direct debit became dormant because it had not been used for more than 12 months. The Council had not needed to collect Council Tax during that period because of the level of Council Tax Support previously awarded.
- The disputed arrears arose when the Council retrospectively revised Mr X's Council Tax Support in August 2023. They did not arise because the Council failed to collect Council Tax by direct debit.
- There was no fault in the Council’s actions on this part of Mr X's complaint.
Communication and correspondence
- The Council did not always communicate clearly with Mr X about the relationship between his Council Tax Support decision, his current-year direct debit and the earlier-year arrears.
- The Council told Mr X in November 2023 that the Benefits Team would contact him. It later accepted this advice was incorrect. It also accepted Mr X had not been properly told that he needed to make a separate payment arrangement for the earlier-year arrears.
- Mr X continued saying he had not received a response to correspondence about the Council Tax Support issue. The Council's records show some correspondence was subsequently passed to the Benefits Team after Mr X raised the absence of a response again.
- The Council also accepted during its complaint investigation that it failed to properly deal with some correspondence because of an administrative filing error.
- The Council therefore failed to give Mr X consistently clear and accurate information about his Council Tax account, the arrears and what he needed to do next. It also failed to properly deal with some of his correspondence. This was fault.
- There was no evidence supporting Mr X's allegations that officers deliberately intercepted, destroyed or concealed his correspondence.
Recovery action
- The Council started, paused and withdrew recovery action on several occasions.
- We cannot investigate the commencement or conduct of proceedings before the Magistrates' Court.
- We can consider the Council's administrative actions leading up to recovery. The evidence shows the Council suspended or withdrew recovery at various points because correspondence remained outstanding, it wanted to check the account, it had given Mr X incorrect information, or it wanted to give him further time to provide the pension evidence.
- The August 2023 Council Tax Support decision remained in place, and the Council was entitled to seek payment of the resulting arrears. There was no separate fault in the Council's decision to recover the arrears. But some of the need to pause or withdraw recovery arose because of the communication faults identified above.
Complaint handling
- The Council took longer than its published timescales to respond to Mr X's complaints.
- The Council took around 48 working days to issue its Stage 1 response when its policy allowed 15 working days, or 25 working days for a complex complaint. It took around 30 working days to issue its Stage 2 response against a 20-working-day target.
- The Council's failure to respond to Mr X's complaints within its published timescales is fault.
- The delays prolonged Mr X's frustration and uncertainty. However, the Council kept recovery action on hold for much of the complaint process, which limited the practical impact of the delays.
Injustice
- The Council's communication and correspondence handling faults caused Mr X avoidable confusion and uncertainty about his Council Tax account and what he needed to do to resolve the position. The problems continued over a prolonged period and the Council itself acknowledged its communications had contributed to Mr X's misunderstanding.
- The complaint handling delays caused Mr X further frustration and prolonged his uncertainty.
- But there is not enough evidence to conclude the Council's faults caused the underlying Council Tax arrears. Those arose from the August 2023 Council Tax Support decision, which Mr X did not appeal.
- Not all the time and trouble Mr X spent pursuing the matter resulted from Council fault. A significant part of the ongoing dispute arose because Mr X disagreed with the Council Tax Support decision but did not use the statutory appeal process or provide the pension evidence the Council requested.
- The Council already apologised, withdrew recovery action and associated costs where its own communication contributed to the problem, and placed Mr X's account on hold on several occasions. These actions addressed some of the injustice caused.
- However, those actions do not fully remedy the avoidable distress and uncertainty caused by the Council's communication and correspondence handling faults over a prolonged period.
Action
- Within one month of our final decision, the Council agreed to:
- Apologise to Mr X for faults identified. We publish guidance on remedies which sets out our expectations for how organisations should apologise effectively to remedy injustice. The organisation should consider this guidance in making the apology I have recommended in my findings.
- Pay £100 to Mr X for the undue distress and uncertainty caused by the faults identified.
- The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above actions.
Decision
- I find fault causing injustice. The Council agreed actions to remedy injustice.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman