Essex County Council (25 021 032)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: We have discontinued our investigation of this complaint, about the Council’s handling of a safeguarding referral. This is because further investigation would not produce a different outcome and would therefore be disproportionate.
The complaint
- I will refer to the complainant as Mrs B. Mrs B is represented in her complaint by a relative, Miss H.
- Miss H complains the Council did not satisfactorily complete enquiries into a safeguarding referral she raised, concerning the standards of care Mrs B was receiving in a care home. She says, because of this, the inadequate care Mrs B was receiving continued, eventually forcing her to leave the home.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’, which we call ‘fault’. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint, which we call ‘injustice’. We provide a free service, but must use public money carefully. We do not start or continue an investigation if we decide we could not add to any previous investigation by the organisation, or that further investigation would not lead to a different outcome. (Local Government Act 1974, section 24A(6), section 34(B))
How I considered this complaint
- I considered evidence provided by Miss H and the Council as well as relevant law, policy and guidance.
- I also shared a draft copy of this decision with each party for their comments.
What I found
- Mrs B had a privately arranged placement in a care home. In August 2025, Miss H submitted a safeguarding referral to the Council, listing a series of concerns about the provider’s care of Miss H and problems with its facilities.
- The Council accepted the referral and carried out enquiries. It arranged an advocate to speak to Mrs B and represent her views, and held a multi-disciplinary team meeting with the care provider and Mrs B’s GP.
- At the end of October, the Council wrote to Miss H. It explained, although it had identified some concerns, the multi-disciplinary team had not substantiated any safeguarding risk to Mrs B. The Council addressed each element of Miss H’s referral, explaining how it had investigated them and the reason for its decision.
- In December Miss H made a complaint to the Ombudsman. She said Mrs B had now had to leave her placement at the care home, which she said was the result of the Council’s flawed safeguarding enquiry.
Analysis
- I do not consider further investigation by the Ombudsman is appropriate in this case.
- I must first explain some important matters of jurisdiction. A council can take responsibility for commissioning a person’s placement in a care home. This means the care home is then acting on that council’s behalf – in effect, as a council contractor – and so the council bears vicarious responsibility for the standard of care it provides.
- However, Mrs B’s placement was arranged privately by her family, and for this reason, the Council had no direct responsibility for the standard of care she received. Although the Council was still involved in its role as safeguarding authority, any complaint (as opposed to a safeguarding concern) Miss H had about the care was a matter for the care provider itself to answer.
- We have jurisdiction to investigate care providers under both circumstances. But as Miss H’s complaint was about the Council, that is the only body I can investigate here; by extension, I am only able to consider how the Council discharged its safeguarding duty. If Miss H wishes to pursue a complaint against the care provider, she will need to do this separately.
- Second, the role of the Ombudsman is to review the way councils have made their decisions. We can criticise a council if we find flaws in the procedure it has followed when making a decision, but we cannot make the decision on the council’s behalf, and we do not provide complainants with a right of appeal.
- In this case, I am satisfied the Council completed its safeguarding enquiries in the proper way. It appointed an advocate to ensure Mrs B’s own views were clearly understood, and arranged a meeting with other relevant bodies in a timely manner. It then explained, in detail, why it had concluded there was no evidence of any safeguarding risk to Mrs B.
- I acknowledge Miss H does not share this view, and she has, in turn, explained why this is. However, it is not my role to repeat the safeguarding enquiry and seek to draw my own conclusions. Absent evidence of fault in the way the Council carried out the enquiries, I have no grounds to uphold her complaint.
- I do note the Council appears to have overlooked one point of Miss H’s referral, in which she said Mrs B was subject to two care plans, neither of which had been fit for purpose.
- While I agree the Council should have addressed this point during its enquiries, I do not consider this justifies further investigation on its own. One of the plans was created by the NHS, which means it falls outside our jurisdiction anyway.
- While the other is in our jurisdiction, Mrs B has now moved to a new placement, and in the process has been subject to a reassessment of her needs and a new care plan. There is nothing meaningful that could now be gained from investigating whether a potential inadequacy in an historic care plan had given rise to a safeguarding risk, especially given the Council’s wider decision there was no reason for such concerns.
- I also note Miss H says the Council did not properly involve her in the safeguarding process. However, Miss H has confirmed she chose not to attend the multi-disciplinary team meeting, despite being invited to it, because she found the process too distressing.
- This was a decision Miss H was entitled to make. But, regardless of her reasons, I cannot criticise the Council for failing to include Miss H in the process, when it was her own decision not to participate in the meeting.
- I am conscious Miss H says the alleged inadequacy in the Council’s safeguarding enquiry meant Mrs B had to leave her placement. The evidence I have seen demonstrates the care provider in fact terminated Mrs B’s placement because it felt its relationship with Miss H had broken down, to the point it could no longer work with her. I do not agree responsibility for this can reasonably be assigned to the Council, regardless of any question about fault in the safeguarding process.
Decision
- I have discontinued my investigation.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman