Liverpool City Council (25 019 334)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: The Council took too long to arrange direct payments after agreeing Ms Y, Mr X’s relative, could support Mr X. It has agreed to apologise to Mr X for the frustration this caused and make a payment to Ms Y to acknowledge the unpaid support she provided. We have not investigated the original delay in assessing Mr X’s needs and reaching a decision on Ms Y supporting him as the complaint was late. It was open to Mr X to complain to us at the time and there are no good reasons to consider this now.
The complaint
- Mr X complained the Council delayed carrying out a needs assessment and producing a support plan which caused him distress and frustration and meant he did not receive direct payments for over two years. Mr X also complained the hourly rate of pay used to calculate his personal budget was too low and the care hours the Council allocated were not sufficient to meet all his eligible needs. Mr X says this has worsened mental health and caused him financial hardship.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
- We cannot investigate late complaints unless we decide there are good reasons. Late complaints are when someone takes more than 12 months to complain to us about something a council has done. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26B and 34D, as amended)
- We consider whether there was fault in the way an organisation made its decision. If there was no fault in how the organisation made its decision, we cannot question the outcome. (Local Government Act 1974, section 34(3), as amended)
- We may investigate matters coming to our attention during an investigation, if we consider that a member of the public who has not complained may have suffered an injustice as a result. (Local Government Act 1974, section 26D and 34E, as amended)
- If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
What I have and have not investigated
- Mr X complained to us in November 2025 about events going back to January 2023 when he requested a needs assessment and personal budget. In August 2024 he complained to the Council about the delay in assessing his needs and agreeing direct payments and the Council responded in September 2024. Its response included our details. Mr X’s complaint about events before November 2024 is late and there are no good reasons to investigate this now. I have considered what happened from October 2024, when Mr X requested a reconsideration of his request for direct payments which is just over 12 months before Mr X complained to us, up until the Council’s complaint response of January 2026.
How I considered this complaint
- I considered evidence provided by Mr X and the Council as well as relevant law, policy and guidance.
- I gave Mr X and the Council an opportunity to comment on my draft decision. I considered any comments before making a final decision.
What I found
Relevant law and guidance
- Sections 9 and 10 of the Care Act 2014 require councils to carry out an assessment for any adult with an appearance of need for care and support. They must provide an assessment to everyone regardless of their finances or whether the council thinks the person has eligible needs. The assessment must be of the adult’s needs, how they impact on their wellbeing and the results they want to achieve. It must also involve the individual and where suitable their carer or any other person they might want involved.
- The Care Act 2014 gives councils a legal responsibility to provide a care and support plan (or a support plan for a carer). The care and support plan should consider what needs the person has, what they want to achieve, what they can do by themselves or with existing support and what care and support may be available in the local area. The support plan must include a personal budget, which is the money the council has worked out it will cost to arrange the necessary care and support for that person.
- The personal budget gives the person clear information about the money allocated to meet the needs identified in the assessment and recorded in the plan. The council should share an indicative amount with the person, and anybody else involved, at the start of care and support planning. It should confirm the final amount of the personal budget through this process. The detail of how the person will use their personal budget will be in the care and support plan. The personal budget must always be enough to meet the person’s care and support needs.
- There are three main ways a personal budget can be administered:
- as a managed account held by the council with support provided in line with the person’s wishes;
- as a managed account held by a third party (often called an individual service fund or ISF) with support provided in line with the person’s wishes; or
- as a direct payment.
Direct payments
- Direct payments are monetary payments made to individuals who ask for one to meet some or all of their eligible care and support needs. They enable people to arrange their own care and support to meet those needs.
- After considering the suitability of the person requesting direct payments against the conditions in the Care Act 2014, the council must decide whether to provide a direct payment. In all cases, the council should consider the request as quickly as possible.
- Direct payments must not be used to pay a close family member unless the Council considers it necessary to do so (The Care and Support (Direct Payments) Regulations 2014.
What happened
- The following is a summary of the main events relevant to the complaint.
- Mr X has chronic fatigue, anxiety and depression. Mr X had previously requested direct payments to pay his relative, Ms Y, to meet his care needs and the Council had refused this as it did not consider his circumstances exceptional enough to agree to someone living in the same household receiving direct payments.
- In October 2024 the Council sent Mr X written confirmation that it did not agree to his request for a direct payment to pay a family member living in the same household. It offered to reassess Mr X’s need for care and support and to further discuss his direct payment request. It also sent him a copy of the needs assessment it had completed in December 2023 which assessed Mr X would benefit from floating support to ensure he maintained a healthy diet, his personal hygiene and household.
- Mr X asked the Council to reconsider his request for direct payments to pay Ms Y. A Council manager told Mr X they would need to reassess his needs, which Mr X agreed to. They also told Mr X they would need to speak with Ms Y to ensure she agreed to provide him with support as a paid personal assistant. This would mean they would need to separate out the support she provided as his relative from the support she would provide as a personal assistant. The Council manager contacted Ms Y who agreed to speak with them later the following month. Ms Y reported things had changed in the last 18 months and Mr X required more support. She reported she would be happy to act as Mr X’s personal assistant but would want to respond to queries in writing. Ms Y wrote to the Council in November 2024 confirming she would be happy to be his paid assistant and setting out the support she provided to Mr X.
- In mid December the Council manager confirmed to Mr X they would agree to recommend Ms Y be employed as Mr X’s personal assistant as an exceptional circumstance.
- Mr X’s social worker sent him a leaflet about charging for care and advised him they would need to update his needs assessment and produce a care and support plan. They agreed to use the information previously provided in writing by Ms Y and Mr X.
- The social worker contacted Mr X in February 2025 to advise him they had completed the needs assessment and support plan and the finance team would be in touch about his contribution to his care charges. The needs assessment recorded Mr X’s chronic fatigue was particularly severe at that time and Ms Y supported him with keeping his room clean, prompting personal care, food shopping and visiting family and friends. The support plan showed Mr X required support with meal preparation, prompting of personal hygiene and medication, and household support.
- Later that month the Council agreed and approved Mr X’s support plan and personal budget. Mr X started to receive direct payments in June 2025 for 12.25 hours of care per week, with effect from the end of March 2025. Mr X asked that his direct payments be backdated. The Council manager responded in early September. They said the direct payment could not be backdated as no formal employment had been established, there was no insurance or payroll facility in place.
- Mr X complained to the Council in September 2025 that the direct payments were not backdated to when he first requested a needs assessment in January 2023. The Council responded in October 2025.
- The Council said an initial assessment was completed in August 2024. A further assessment was completed in February 2025. The social worker then worked with Mr X to develop his care and support plan which they completed in late March 2025. It said there was a delay as Mr X’s needs were clarified and it explored how best to arrange a direct payment where someone in the same household provided support. It explained that following discussions at senior management level it agreed Mr X had exceptional circumstances. It said there was a pause between February and August 2024 which the Council was responsible for and offered Mr X £200 in recognition of the impact the delay had on him.
- Mr X complained again in October 2025. He was unhappy with the personal budget which he considered was insufficient to meet his care needs and the hourly rate of pay which was at the rate of the minimum wage which he said would not enable him to purchase care from someone privately.
- The Council responded to Mr X in January 2026. It said it set its own standard direct payment rate which was linked to the national minimum wage. It said alternative support options were available which included Mr X commissioning support through an agency, the Council commissioning support for Mr X or a combination of both.
- It said Mr X’s social worker completed his needs assessment and concluded Mr X should receive 1 hour 45 minutes of support each day. The Council had also agreed that this could be used to pay a family member due to Mr X’s exceptional circumstances. It was satisfied the direct payment was determined by Mr X’s eligible care needs and was not fault. It said it had offered to complete a review of his care and support needs. However, Mr X had wished to await the outcome of the complaint. It said the Council would review his care and support needs and could offer a meeting with the direct payment team to explain the rates of pay and options available.
- Mr X remained unhappy and complained to us.
Findings
Not backdating direct payments
- As explained above, I have not considered what happened before October 2024.
- In October 2024, Mr X requested a reconsideration of the decision not to pay his relative, Ms Y, to provide him with support. The Council agreed to this but as part of the process needed to review Mr X’s needs assessment to ensure it was up to date as part of the process of developing a support plan and agreeing his personal budget. Mr X’s direct payments commenced in late March 2025. Although the records show the Council was taking action to move this forward, the whole process took too long.
- We would generally have expected this to have taken around eight to twelve weeks, rather than the five to six months it took. This delay was fault. Whilst this delay caused Mr X frustration, during this time there is no evidence Mr X had unmet care needs as Ms Y provided him with support. However, Ms Y providing support to Mr X on an unpaid basis was an injustice to her. As I have explained at paragraph 5 above, we have the power to investigate matters coming to our attention during an investigation if we think a member of the public has or may have suffered an injustice as a result and can make recommendations to remedy this injustice. As there was no contractual employment relationship in place, Ms Y was not completing timesheets and I cannot now establish exactly what support she provided, I cannot recommend the Council backdate the direct payments. I have therefore recommended the Council make a symbolic payment to Ms Y to acknowledge the impact of providing unpaid support to Mr X.
Rate of pay of personal assistant
- It is for the Council to decide the hourly rate it will normally pay. Ms Y is supporting Mr X and therefore the rate is sufficient to meet Mr X’s eligible care needs. If Mr X wishes to recruit a different personal assistant and has difficulties due to the rate of pay it is open to him to approach the Council about this, at that time.
Hours of support
- The Ombudsman is not an appeal body. It is not for the Ombudsman to say what level of care is appropriate to meet Mr X’s needs. We can only look at how the Council made its decisions and whether there was fault in the process it used to make those decisions.
- The Council assessed Mr X’s eligible care needs and produced a care and support plan based on this. It took into account information provided by Mr X and Ms Y. There is no evidence of fault in the way it has done this. It has offered Mr X a review to consider if his needs have changed or more support is required. That is what we would expect it to do. The Council is not at fault.
Agreed Action
- Within one month of the final decision the Council has agreed to:
- apologise to Mr X for the frustration caused by the delay in arranging direct payments once it agreed Ms Y could support Mr X; and
- pay Ms X £300 to acknowledge the impact of providing unpaid support during this period. This is separate to the £200 the Council offered Mr X in its complaint response of October 2025 as that related to the Council’s acceptance of delay causing injustice during February to August 2024, which is a period I have not investigated.
- The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above actions.
Decision
- I find fault causing injustice which the Council has agreed to remedy.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman