Kirklees Metropolitan Borough Council (25 007 342)

Category : Adult care services > Direct payments

Decision : Upheld

Decision date : 10 Sep 2026

The Ombudsman's final decision:

Summary: Miss X complained about the Council’s actions relating to her relative, Miss Y’s, care and support plan. We found fault because the Council failed to adequately explain that direct payments in Miss Y’s plan were being removed. This caused Miss Y avoidable distress and frustration. To remedy this injustice, the Council has agreed to apologise to Miss Y.

The complaint

  1. Miss X complains the Council’s assessment of her relative, Miss Y’s, care and support needs was flawed. She says personal assistant care and support hours have been withdrawn for Miss Y when they should not have been. She also complains care and support hours designed to be delivered by Miss Y’s supported living provider are not being accessed by her and funds should be redirected to support her in a different way.
  2. Miss X says Miss Y is not accessing appropriate support and this is affecting her quality of life causing her distress and frustration.

Back to top

The Ombudsman’s role and powers

  1. We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may suggest a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
  2. We may investigate complaints made on behalf of someone else if they have given their consent. (Local Government Act 1974, section 26A(1), as amended)
  3. If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)

Back to top

What I have and have not investigated

  1. My investigation begins when Miss Y’s family asked for a reassessment of her care and support needs in September 2024.
  2. My investigation ends when the Council issued its final complaint response at the end of June 2025.

Back to top

How I considered this complaint

  1. I have considered all the information Miss X provided. I have also asked the Council questions and requested information, and in turn have considered the Council’s response.
  2. Miss X and the Council had the opportunity to comment on my draft decision. I have taken any comments received into consideration before reaching my final decision.

Back to top

What I found

Assessment

  1. Sections 9 and 10 of the Care Act 2014 require councils to carry out an assessment for any adult with an appearance of need for care and support. They must provide an assessment to everyone regardless of their finances or whether the council thinks the person has eligible needs. The assessment must be of the adult’s needs and how they impact on their wellbeing and the results they want to achieve. It must also involve the individual and where suitable their carer or any other person they might want involved.

Care plan

  1. The Care Act 2014 gives councils a legal responsibility to provide a care and support plan. The care and support plan should consider what needs the person has, what they want to achieve, what they can do by themselves or with existing support and what care and support may be available in the local area. The support plan must include a personal budget, which is the money the council has worked out it will cost to arrange the necessary care and support for that person.

Personal budgets

  1. Everyone whose needs the council meets must receive a personal budget as part of the care and support plan. The personal budget gives the person clear information about the money allocated to meet the needs identified in the assessment and recorded in the plan. The detail of how the person will use their personal budget will be in the care and support plan. The personal budget must always be enough to meet the person’s care and support needs.
  2. One of the ways a personal budget can be administered is via a direct payment (DP). (Care and Support Statutory Guidance 2014 (the CSSG))

Direct payments

  1. DPs are monetary payments made to individuals who ask for them to meet some or all of their eligible care and support needs. They enable people to arrange their own care and support to meet those needs.
  2. Section 12.73 of the CSSG says the local authority might also discontinue payments if for some reason it no longer believes it is appropriate to make the direct payments.
  3. Section 12.80 of the CSSG says in all cases, as soon as possible, the local authority should discuss with individuals, their carers and any person managing the direct payments if it is considering discontinuing DPs to them.

Revising a care and support plan

  1. Section 13.27 of the CSSG says that when revising the plan the local authority must involve the person, their carer and any other persons the adult may want involved, and their advocate where the person qualifies for one. The local authority must take all reasonable steps to agree the revision.

Review of an amended care and support plan

  1. Section 13.32 of the CSSG expects that authorities should consider a light touch review six to eight weeks after agreement and sign off of a revised plan. This is to ensure that the new plan is working as intended.

Mental Capacity Act

  1. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 is the framework for acting and deciding for people who lack the mental capacity to make particular decisions for themselves. The Act (and the Code of Practice 2007) describes the steps a person should take when dealing with someone who may lack capacity to make decisions for themselves. It describes when to assess a person’s capacity to make a decision, how to do this, and how to make a decision on behalf of somebody who cannot do so.

Mental capacity assessment

  1. A person aged 16 or over must be presumed to have capacity to make a decision unless it is established they lack capacity. A person should not be treated as unable to make a decision:
  • because they make an unwise decision;
  • based simply on: their age; their appearance; assumptions about their condition, or any aspect of their behaviour; or
  • before all practicable steps to help the person to do so have been taken without success.
  1. The council must assess someone’s ability to make a decision when that person’s capacity is in doubt. How it assesses capacity may vary depending on the complexity of the decision.

What happened

  1. I have set out below a summary of the key events. This is not meant to show everything that happened.
  2. Miss Y is an adult with additional needs and learning difficulties. She lives in supported living accommodation in the Council’s area, Accommodation A. Miss Y was assessed as having capacity to make decisions about her care and support needs but not about finances. Miss Y had a historic care and support plan in place at the beginning of my investigation period. The plan was dated May 2023.
  3. Miss Y’s care plan included 10 hours per week support from a personal assistant (PA). Miss Y’s PA hours were delivered by Miss X. The hours were for flexible support outside of Accommodation A for things such as engaging in activities and accessing the community, support to manage behaviour, reduce risk and promote independence. These were paid via DP.
  4. Miss Y’s care plan included 10 support hours per week delivered at and by staff from Accommodation A. The plan also included 6 domiciliary support hours per week at Accommodation A but which were delivered by an outside agency, Agency A.

Care assessment and planning

  1. Miss Y’s family contacted the Council late in September 2024 and asked for a reassessment of her care and support needs to be carried out.
  2. The Council visited Miss Y and her family at the family home at the beginning of October 2024. The assessment documents noted that Miss Y’s family were concerned about her behaviour when visiting the family home.
  3. The Council and Miss Y’s family continued to communicate throughout the coming months.

2025

  1. In January, the Council became aware of concerns about incidents involving Miss Y at Accommodation A and her existing support arrangements. The family also contacted the Council again to voice concerns about Miss Y’s behaviour and presentation when attending the family home.
  2. Also in January, Agency A told the Council it was giving notice on its services. It said Miss Y wanted to cancel the support in place as she did not want it any more. Agency A confirmed that Miss Y had not been accessing the support and was either not there to receive it, asked staff to leave or for them to transport her to the family home.
  3. The Council met with the family and staff from Accommodation A in mid-February. It met with Miss Y separately. Parties agreed for 6-weekly meetings to review the situation and to discuss Miss Y’s case and accommodation.
  4. In April, the Council again met with the family, Miss Y and staff from Accommodation A. The Council agreed to make a referral to a company who could deal with Miss Y’s finances, with a view to dealing with significant arrears on Miss Y’s rent account at Accommodation A.
  5. Miss Y’s care and support plan (the plan) was finalised at the end of April.
  6. In early May, an officer reviewing the Council’s work on the case noted that DPs for Miss X to act as a PA for Miss Y were still active on the account. The Council contacted the company paying the invoices to ask why Miss X was still being paid as a PA when Miss Y had a number of support hours in place through Accommodation A.
  7. A manager at the Council completed a case audit in mid-May. The audit:
    • signed off the plan;
    • identified a reduction in core hours at Accommodation A due to how this was split amongst residents; and
    • identified a reduction in one-to-one support hours to promote independence.
  8. The revised plan still included:
    • hours split between Miss Y and other residents at Accommodation A; and
    • 10 hours of one-to-one support per week to be delivered to Miss Y on site by Accommodation A’s staff.
  9. The same afternoon, Miss X contacted the Council. Amongst other things, she was unhappy with the level of contact from the Council and said both her and Miss Y wanted the 10 hours of DP reinstated. DPs were ended a week after the plan was signed off. Communication between the Miss X and the Council continued.
  10. The Council sent its first and final complaint response to Miss X late in June. In this, it said:
    • Accommodation A was a supported living service. It allowed Miss Y to access her allotted support hours as and when she chose and that she had capacity to make such decisions;
    • the care and support assessment confirmed Accommodation A was providing appropriate support and met Miss Y’s assessed needs;
    • the Council generally discouraged relatives acting as a personal assistant to family members due to a risk of care breakdown;
    • the Care Act promoted and encouraged choice and support outside of the family to build social connections and independence;
    • the Council had discussed the fact the DP would stop with other members of the family as Miss Y did not have capacity to manage finances;
    • that Miss X was not consulted as part of the assessment process as a different family member had been representing Miss Y at the time; and
    • that current support arrangements would remain in place.
  11. The Council signposted Miss X to us and she brought her complaint to us in mid-August.

Analysis

Direct payment hours reduction

  1. The care and support plan references that the Council had spoken to family members as part of the reassessment process. When Miss Y’s father asked if she could have a PA, the social worker questioned whether this would be suitable as Miss Y would need to accept the support provided. The plan also referenced that the family had previously said they were not able to support Miss Y. The plan noted that PA hours would be stopped.
  2. On the point that Miss X and Miss Y wanted the DPs reinstated, I am satisfied the Council has shown adequate consideration of the circumstances of the case. It made a reasoned decision on what Miss Y’s eligible needs were. It considered the background of Miss Y not wishing to engage with support at all or not regularly choosing to engage. Removing the DPs for Miss Y having a family member as her PA was a decision the Council was entitled to make. I find no fault in its actions here.
  3. However, I am not persuaded the family or Miss Y were adequately aware that the existing 10 PA hours would be stopped before the plan was finalised. I acknowledge the plan mentions stopping them, however, although the plan was dated 29 April 2025, it was not signed off by a manager until 14 May 2025.
  4. Case records from 8 May 2025 show that the Council noted Miss Y’s DPs were still paying for Miss X’s 10 hours of support per week. The Council wanted to challenge this with the payroll company who dealt with it because support was being provided by Accommodation A. After this case note, a manager’s audit of the case file on 14 May 2025 then signed off the plan and removed the one-to-one hours to support independence, after which Miss X complained.
  5. In response to my enquiries, the Council said Miss Y and the family were consulted during the assessment and care planning process, which I acknowledge and agree with. However, the Council also said it had no clear record that specifically showed evidence the proposed withdrawal was discussed with them before the decision had been put in place.
  6. The CSSG outlines that any consideration of whether to stop DPs should be discussed as soon as possible and before making the final decision to end them.
  7. The CSSG also states all reasonable steps should be taken to agree any revision in the plan.
  8. Not discussing the decision to end the 10 hours PA support delivered by Miss X before the plan was signed off was fault. This caused Miss Y avoidable distress and frustration. I have made a recommendation below to remedy this injustice.

Support hours at Accommodation A

  1. Miss X complains Miss Y was not accessing support hours designed to be delivered at Accommodation A and that these should be redirected elsewhere.
  2. In response to my enquiries, the Council said Miss Y did not consistently wish to engage with support available at Accommodation A. It said this pattern extended to support offered by Agency A and a referral to an outside agency. It also said assessment showed Miss Y would sometimes ask for support but then decline, disengage or change her mind and that her response to support was very variable.
  3. I am satisfied the Council has shown it adequately considered how Miss Y’s eligible care needs could be met and in doing so has kept the support hours in place at Accommodation A for if and when she chooses to engage. Based on its assessment of her eligible needs, the Council does not consider Miss Y requires additional support to be in place. This is a decision for the Council to make. I find no fault in its actions.

Light touch review

  1. The CSSG states that councils should consider a light touch review after six to eight weeks of a revised plan being in place.
  2. In response to my enquiries, the Council said it had not formally carried out a light touch review at the time. The Council said there was ongoing contact with the family after the plan had been signed off, including discussions about the DP and the complaint response. The Council said it had also been in contact with Accommodation A about support and Miss Y’s actions.
  3. I am satisfied there is no fault on the Council’s part here. It chose not to complete a formal light touch review, as was its decision to make, but continued to liaise around the plan where necessary.

Back to top

Agreed action

  1. To remedy the injustice caused by the fault I have identified, the Council has agreed to apologise to Miss Y for the identified injustice within four weeks of the date of my final decision.
  2. The apology written should be in line with the Ombudsman’s guidance on remedies on making an effective apology.
  3. The Council should provide us with evidence it has complied with the above action.

Back to top

Final decision

  1. I have now completed my investigation. I uphold this complaint with a finding of fault causing an injustice.

Back to top

Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman

Print this page

LGO logogram

Review your privacy settings

Required cookies

These cookies enable the website to function properly. You can only disable these by changing your browser preferences, but this will affect how the website performs.

View required cookies

Analytical cookies

Google Analytics cookies help us improve the performance of the website by understanding how visitors use the site.
We recommend you set these 'ON'.

View analytical cookies

In using Google Analytics, we do not collect or store personal information that could identify you (for example your name or address). We do not allow Google to use or share our analytics data. Google has developed a tool to help you opt out of Google Analytics cookies.

Privacy settings