Derbyshire County Council (23 003 655)

Category : Education > School admissions

Decision : Not upheld

Decision date : 16 Oct 2023

The Ombudsman's final decision:

Summary: there is no fault in the Independent Appeal Panel’s decision not to admit Ms M’s daughter to a secondary school. The Ombudsman cannot question decisions made without fault.

The complaint

  1. Ms M complains about an Independent Appeal Panel’s decision not to admit her daughter to a secondary school.
  2. In particular, Ms M complains the officer presenting the case for the admission authority referred to the fact she lives “across the border” in a different council area a number of times. Ms M believes this may have prejudiced the Panel.
  3. Ms M complains parents were not told the questions the Panel would ask them in advance, which she believes disadvantaged her.
  4. Ms M complains the documents she sent with her appeal were not given to the Panel until the hearing. She does not believe the Panel had sufficient time to consider them and believes their decision may have been different if they had.
  5. Ms M complains she was not given an opportunity to ‘sum up’ at the end of the hearing.

Back to top

The Ombudsman’s role and powers

  1. We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We cannot question a school admission appeal panel’s decision simply because the complainant disagrees with it. We must consider if there was fault in the way the decision was reached. (Local Government Act 1974, section 34(3))
  2. We check the Independent Appeal Panel followed the Code of Practice issued by the Department for Education and the hearing was fair.  We do this by examining the notes taken by the Clerk during the hearing.  We do not have the power to overturn the Panel’s decision, and we cannot give a child a place at the school. If we find fault, which calls the panel’s decision into question, we may ask for a new appeal hearing.
  3. If we are satisfied with a panel’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(i), as amended)

Back to top

How I considered this complaint

  1. I have considered:
    • Ms M’s comments;
    • all the information presented to the Appeal Panel, the notes taken by the Clerk during the appeal, and the Panel’s decision letter following the appeal; and
    • the School Admissions Appeals Code 2022.
  2. I invited Ms M and the Council to comment on my draft decision.

Back to top

What I found

  1. The school is a voluntary controlled school. The Council is the admission authority and is responsible for admissions and appeals.
  2. Ms M’s application for a place and her subsequent appeal were unsuccessful. Ms M complained to the Ombudsman.
  3. The Ombudsman checks the appeal was carried out properly. We do not decide whether Ms M’s daughter should be given a place at the school.
  4. The School Admission Appeals Code 2022 issued by the Department for Education sets out the process the Independent Appeal Panel must follow when considering an appeal.
  5. The Panel must first check the admission arrangements were properly applied. Ms M’s application was unsuccessful because she does not live in the normal admissions area for the school and her daughter would not have an eligible sibling at the school at the time of her admission. There were more applications than places available in this category, so places were allocated to children living closest to the school. The last child admitted lived closer to the school than Ms M. The Panel was satisfied the admission arrangements had been correctly applied.
  6. The Panel must then decide whether the school can accept any more pupils. The Panel concluded the school was full. There is no fault in the Panel’s decision.
  7. The Panel must then consider the case for the admission of Ms M’s daughter. I have not repeated the details of Ms M’s appeal here to protect her anonymity. The Panel must decide whether the prejudice to Ms M’s daughter of being refused a place outweighs the prejudice to the school of admitting another pupil. The Panel decided it did not. There is no fault in the Panel’s decision. I will address Ms M’s complaints below.

The presenting officer’s references to Ms M living “across the border”

  1. Ms M complains the officer presenting the case for the admission authority referred to the fact she lived “across the border” in a different council area a number of times. Ms M believes this may have prejudiced the Appeal Panel.
  2. The school’s admission arrangements give priority to children who live in the “normal admissions area” for the school. This is a pre-defined area of the County. Ms M does not live in the area. In fact, she does not live in the County. The fact she lives “across the border” is, therefore, relevant to her application since it places here in the lowest priority of the oversubscription criteria. There was no fault mentioning the fact at the appeal, and there is no evidence it prejudiced the Panel.

Notifying parents of the questions in advance

  1. Ms M complains parents were not told the questions the Panel would ask them in advance, which she believes disadvantaged them.
  2. There is no requirement to notify parents in advance the questions the Panel will ask. To do so could, in fact, limit the Panel’s ability to explore a parent’s reasons for wanting a particular school. Parents should be prepared to answer questions about their reasons for wanting a particular school.

The late delivery of documents

  1. Ms M complains the documents she sent with her appeal were not given to the Panel until the hearing. She does not believe the Panel had sufficient time to consider them and believes their decision may have been different if they had.
  2. It is regrettable the Panel was not provided with Ms M’s documents in advance, and getting the documents to the Panel at the start of the hearing will have been an unwelcome distraction.
  3. The documents in question were four short letters. The minutes of the discussion at the hearing show the Panel asked Ms M questions based on the letters. This satisfies me the Panel was able to properly consider the evidence during the hearing.

An opportunity to ‘sum up’

  1. Ms M complains she was not given an opportunity to ‘sum up’ at the end of the hearing.
  2. There is no requirement to give parents an opportunity to sum up. While it might be good practice to check the parent has had an opportunity to say all they want to in the appeal, it is for the Chair of the Panel to manage the hearing.

Back to top

Final decision

  1. I have ended my investigation. There is no fault in the appeal. The Ombudsman cannot question decisions made without fault.

Investigator’s decision on behalf of the Ombudsman

Back to top

Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman

Print this page

LGO logogram

Review your privacy settings

Required cookies

These cookies enable the website to function properly. You can only disable these by changing your browser preferences, but this will affect how the website performs.

View required cookies

Analytical cookies

Google Analytics cookies help us improve the performance of the website by understanding how visitors use the site.
We recommend you set these 'ON'.

View analytical cookies

In using Google Analytics, we do not collect or store personal information that could identify you (for example your name or address). We do not allow Google to use or share our analytics data. Google has developed a tool to help you opt out of Google Analytics cookies.

Privacy settings