Derby City Council (25 012 465)
The Ombudsman's final decision:
Summary: We found no fault on Mr Y’s complaint about the way the Council dealt with his neighbour over reported breaches of planning consent. The Council took his reports seriously, challenged the neighbour about the accuracy of submitted plans compared to what was being built, took an informal approach to get compliance rather than formal enforcement action, and considered the impact on amenities. There was no evidence of the Council giving him inaccurate and incorrect advice.
The complaint
- Mr Y complains that when he contacted the Council about a neighbour breaching planning consent, it failed to:
- properly, and promptly, act on his reports;
- check the accuracy of plans submitted for retrospective planning consent;
- properly consider its impact on his amenities; and
- give him accurate and correct advice.
- As a result, this has affected him and his family’s health and well-being, made him vulnerable with his neighbour, and the development has encroached on to his land.
The Ombudsman’s role and powers
- If we are satisfied with an organisation’s actions or proposed actions, we can complete our investigation and issue a decision statement. (Local Government Act 1974, section 30(1B) and 34H(1), as amended)
- We investigate complaints about ‘maladministration’ and ‘service failure’. In this statement, I have used the word fault to refer to these. We must also consider whether any fault has had an adverse impact on the person making the complaint. I refer to this as ‘injustice’. If there has been fault which has caused significant injustice, or that could cause injustice to others in the future we may recommend a remedy. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26(1) and 26A(1), as amended)
- We cannot investigate late complaints unless we decide there are good reasons. Late complaints are when someone takes more than 12 months to complain to us about something a council has done. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26B and 34D, as amended)
What I have and have not investigated
- I have not investigated the following:
- Any complaint Mr Y has about the Council approving the original planning application (application 1) and notifying him of its decision. We cannot investigate late complaints unless we decide there are good reasons. Late complaints are when someone takes more than 12 months to complain to us about something a council has done. (Local Government Act 1974, sections 26B and 34D, as amended).
The Council granted planning consent in July 2023, and Mr Y complained to us in September 2025. We usually would not look at events before September 2024 unless there were good reasons to do so. I have seen no good reason why we should do so.
- Any complaint Mr Y has about his neighbour encroaching on to his land. This is because he can ask the courts to look and decide this as it is a private civil matter.
How I considered this complaint
- I considered evidence provided by Mr Y, the notes I made of our telephone conversation, the Council’s response to my enquiries, as well as relevant law, policy, and guidance. I sent a copy of my draft decision to Mr Y and the Council. I considered their responses.
What I found
Planning enforcement
- Councils can take enforcement action if they find planning rules have been breached. Councils should not take enforcement action just because there has been a breach of planning control.
- Planning enforcement is discretionary, and formal action should happen only when it would be a proportionate response to the breach. When deciding whether to enforce, councils should consider the likely impact of harm to the public and whether they might grant approval if they were to receive an application for the development or use.
- As planning enforcement action is discretionary, councils may decide to take informal action or not to act at all. Informal action might include negotiating improvements, seeking an assurance or undertaking, or requesting submission of a planning application so they can formally consider the issues.
- Government guidance in force at the time says: “Effective enforcement is important as a means of maintaining public confidence in the planning system. Enforcement action is discretionary, and local planning authorities should act proportionately in responding to suspected breaches of planning control.” (National Planning Policy Framework December 2024, paragraph 60)
What happened
- Mr Y’s neighbour applied to the Council for planning consent to extend his property (application 1). The Council approved the application, and his neighbour began carrying out works on his property.
- The Council received a retrospective planning application (application 2) in early 2024 for changes to the approved consent. It explained after receiving it, there were ongoing negotiations with the neighbour and his agents to ensure the drawings for it accurately showed what was built.
- Mr Y reported the neighbour to the Council because of failures to carry out the works according to planning consent. His reports included the neighbour’s works encroaching on to his property, particularly with a canopy to the front of the house which he said overhung his land. He also reported the replacement rear garden brick wall along their boundary.
- A planning officer visited Mr Y and found although the rear ground level was raised by the neighbour, following the involvement of the planning enforcement team, it was reduced back to its original level.
- During a site visit, Mr Y and the neighbour discussed the fencing and the site. There was discussion about raising the wall height near to the rear wall of Mr Y’s property to protect amenities. The officer also noted a raised patio area was larger than shown on plans. Later, there was an issue with the neighbour’s ground floor canopy at the front of his house.
- The planning officer confirmed there was a period during which attempts were made to resolve issues. This involved ensuring all deviations were on amended version of drawings. The Council did not consider these were enough, in themselves, to justify taking formal action. The Council confirmed enforcement action would have been a wholly disproportionate response in these circumstances.
- In July, the Council responded to Mr Y’s reports. This apologised for the delay responding to him and dealt with the following concerns:
- Width of patio and wall: the officer noted the width increase was a small increase and asked what impact this had on Mr Y’s amenities.
- The length of the patio was less than shown on plans: the officer would seek clarification on this.
- The height of the wall alongside the road was higher than approved: this would be clarified but did not appear unduly oppressive in terms of height/appearance in the street scene. The Council noted enclosing walls and fencing can be built up to two metres anyway.
- The canopy to the front is not on the approved plans: the officer agreed this needed rectifying but was a modest increase in its width to what was previously there. Its impact on Mr Y’s amenities was questioned. It was not a change that had a detrimental impact on the character of the wider street scene and was common in residential areas.
- Mr Y claimed when the neighbour made planning applications, he gave misleading information which the Council failed to check. He complained about how the Council dealt with his reports, including the time taken to ensure compliance.
- In November, another neighbour contacted the Council about concerns with works to the boundary.
- In response to our enquiries, the Council confirmed officers investigated Mr Y’s reports and found the neighbour’s works did not fully comply with planning consent. Officers visited the site on several occasions and met with Mr Y and other neighbours. Some of the unauthorised works were removed and the Council asked the neighbour to send a retrospective planning application for the remaining unauthorised works.
- The delay dealing with the application was due to issues with the drawings submitted along with ongoing changes as the works developed and progressed.
- The Council approved application 2 in June 2025, 16 months after validating it. The application, and the removal of certain unauthorised works, addressed the breaches of planning control. It confirmed works encroaching on to Mr Y’s land, or boundary issues, are not planning matters and the Council suggested he get legal advice. It noted the drawings from the neighbour for planning consent related only to the neighbour’s property.
- The Council noted one condition has still to be discharged which was to provide an amended plan which it needed to approve showing the vehicle access and gates at the correctly installed height, along with the boundary wall and privacy screens. A recent application to discharge it was refused because the plan did not reflect the previously discussed boundary treatments.
My findings
Complaint a): properly, and promptly, act on his reports
- The evidence satisfies me there was no fault on this complaint. This is because I have seen copies of emails between the Council and the agent. The evidence shows the Council became aware some of the works did not comply with approved planning consent. The Council had discretion to take informal action and not take formal enforcement action. This typically involves entering into a dialogue to negotiate to ensure works complied with planning consent.
- The evidence shows the Council entered into a dialogue with the agent about the works which needed amended plans or an application to seek a variation to get consent for amended plans. This was because it decided this was the most proportionate response for dealing with the works which did not comply. The Council was entitled to reach this view after considering all relevant circumstances.
Complaint b): check the accuracy of plans submitted for retrospective planning consent
- The evidence shows there was correspondence between the Council and the agent about the plans and site visits done which resulted in recommendations to amend them. The evidence shows the agent discussing issues raised with the neighbour and making changes.
- When the Council received amended plans, there was email contact with the agent about them. For example, this contact covered gates being shown lower than what was in place, the depth of the front canopy, along with a request for confirmation it did not encroach on Mr Y’s property.
- I have seen numerous examples of the Council bringing the agent’s attention to inaccuracies between the plans and what was being built. Correspondence shows the agent was asked about submitting a new application to regularise works built and plans that need varying. There was also evidence of the Council chasing the agent for information and applications.
Complaint c): properly consider its impact on his amenities
- I found no fault on this complaint. The evidence shows the Council considered the impact on amenities. I say this because the impact on amenities was raised on numerous occasions in emails with the agent.
Complaint d): give him accurate and correct advice
- I found no evidence of the Council giving Mr Y wrong advice.
Decision
- I found no fault on Mr Y’s complaint against the Council.
Investigator's decision on behalf of the Ombudsman